Settlement Sheets You Never See Or Verify - Traps & Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

If you think your music money is safe because a label or distributor emailed you a royalty check once a year, think again. There are whole invisible spreadsheets, secret deductions, and corporate math tricks designed to make sure what you expected as money turns into something that looks like a math problem and not a paycheck. This article will make you paranoid in the best possible way. You will learn what those hidden settlement sheets are. You will learn the scams people use. You will learn how to actually verify numbers, ask for the right documents, and force transparency like a boss.

We wrote this for musicians who want to keep more of what they earn. You do not need a law degree to follow this. You need curiosity, persistence, and a few templates to send when accountants act shady. Expect real life scenarios, clear explanations for terms and acronyms, and practical checklists you can use today.

What Is a Settlement Sheet Anyway

A settlement sheet is the detailed accounting a payer sends to the person or company that owns the rights to a sound recording or composition. That payer can be a label, a distributor, a streaming service, a publisher, or a collection society. The settlement sheet shows how much money was generated, how it was split, and what deductions were taken. Yet musicians rarely see the full, raw settlement sheet from the upstream payer. You usually get a summary or a payment stub not the full back office report. That missing paper trail is where problems live.

Examples of common settlement sheets

• Label accounting statements that summarize income and expenses from digital service providers and physical sales
• Distributor remittance reports from companies that aggregate DSP payments
• Performance Royalty statements from performing rights organizations also called PROs like ASCAP, BMI, or SESAC
• Sound recording performance statements from SoundExchange in the United States
• Mechanical royalty statements from entities like the Mechanical Licensing Collective or HFA which is the Harry Fox Agency
• Neighboring rights statements from PPL UK or local collecting societies in other countries

Quick acronym guide because the music industry loves acronyms and you need to look smart

• DSP means Digital Service Provider. These are Spotify, Apple Music, Amazon Music, YouTube Music, and similar services.
• PRO means Performing Rights Organization. PROs collect public performance royalties for songwriters and publishers. Examples are ASCAP, BMI, SESAC in the US, PRS in the UK, SOCAN in Canada.
• ISRC stands for International Standard Recording Code. It is a unique identifier for a master recording. Think of it like a barcode for a song file.
• UPC stands for Universal Product Code. It identifies a release or product, like an album or single.
• Mechanical royalties pay songwriters for reproductions, including streams in some markets. In the US the Mechanical Licensing Collective or MLC collects these for interactive streaming mechanicals.
• SoundExchange collects digital performance royalties for sound recordings for non interactive digital radio and some streaming uses in the US.
• Recoupment means the label or payer deducts expenses they paid on your behalf from your earnings until they have been recovered.

The Ugly Truth

Most artists do not see the full settlement sheets that come from DSPs. Labels and distributors get massive, granular reports. Those reports list streams, territories, ISRCs, UPCs, play counts, gross income, deductions, prorated rates, reserves, chargebacks, and fees. The version you get is often a one page summary or an aggregate that hides the detail. That is not always malicious. Sometimes it is a workflow problem. More often it is an opportunity to take money that artists did not know existed.

Real life example

Rae had a viral song and signed a one album distribution deal with a boutique label. She received a quarterly statement showing $5000 gross and a $4800 recoup balance so she got $200. She thought that was fair until she hired an auditor. The audit found that the label had received $18,000 from DSPs for the song but had shifted $10,000 into a reserve account for returns and reseller chargebacks. Those reserves were never cleared and the label deducted manufacturing costs the label never actually paid. The label also misapplied a publishing split to master income. Long story short Rae was owed thousands more. The audit demanded the hidden settlement sheets from the DSPs and the label could not justify the deductions. Rae ended up with a six figure correction and a lot less trust in boutique labels.

Why Labels And Distributors Withhold The Full Settlement Sheets

Most of the time it is about leverage. If you do not see details you cannot dispute them easily. Here are common reasons they do not show the full reports

• Data overload. They will claim too much data is confusing so they provide an abstracted summary.
• Protecting trade secrets. They might say revealing payout algorithms is business confidential.
• They want flexibility. If you cannot trace a deduction you are less likely to ask hard questions.
• Human laziness. Accounting teams operate with standard workflows that do not include exporting raw DSP reports into artist portals.

Top Scams And Traps You Must Watch For

We split these into label side scams, distributor scams, and collector society problems so you can keep your eye on the right ball.

Label And Contract Traps

• Phantom Expenses

Labels will charge for promotion, radio plugging, video budgets, mastering, manufacturing and even photography. Sometimes those charges are legitimate. Other times they are exaggerated or never happened. The contract often allows labels to deduct these costs from your artist share until they are recouped. Without invoices you cannot verify the cost.

• Cross Collateralization

This clause allows the label to apply income from one project to recoup expenses from another. You might think one hit single paid off an album budget. Not if your deal lets the label shift money across releases. That single could disappear into an old debt from a previous non performing release.

• Chargebacks And Reserve Accounts

Labels will hold a reserve for returns on physical sales and sometimes apply similar logic to digital. They call it a reserve for chargebacks. Labels can keep paying you lower amounts while they hold millions in reserves. Some labels unreasonably inflate the reserve percentage.

• Controlled Composition Clauses

If you signed a recording deal and you are a songwriter you may have inadvertently accepted a compulsory or reduced mechanical rate for your compositions used in the masters. That reduces your publishing income and sometimes creates strange accounting where your master payments are debited to reconcile the lower mechanical.

• Manipulated Splits

Labels sometimes confuse composition and master income on statements so they can deduct publishing obligations from master receipts or vice versa. If the split is wrong you will never know unless you check the ISRCs and match them to publishing splits.

Distributor And Aggregator Scams

• Hidden Fees

Some aggregators keep an unspecified admin fee and bury it in the settlement. Others will say they take a commission for promo or playlisting while never showing the invoices. Always insist on a line by line fee amount with supporting documentation.

• Ownership Claims

Watch for terms where you grant the aggregator the right to re assign rights for the purpose of distribution without a clear duration and reversion clause. You do not want someone else owning a license because you clicked accept while distracted and drunk on free promo.

• Unpaid Mechanical And Neighboring Rights

Many aggregators only handle master distribution and leave mechanicals and neighboring rights uncollected. They might promise to collect everything but never enroll the works in the proper collecting agencies. That money can sit unclaimed or be incorrectly credited to someone else.

Collection Society And DSP Reporting Problems

• Incorrect Metadata

If your ISRC, songwriter splits, or publisher information is wrong your money will go to someone else. DSPs and PROs match by metadata. A single typo in an ISRC can route thousands to a different account or leave money unclaimed in black boxes.

• Pro Rata Pooling And Per Stream Rates

DSPs usually pay out from a pool based on total subscription revenue divided by total streams, then multiplied by your share of streams. That makes per stream rates variable and confusing. Some aggregators miscalculate your share or use the wrong pool to show lower rates. You need detailed play counts and net revenue numbers to confirm the math.

• Unexplained Deductions For Content ID Or Claims

On platforms like YouTube you might see Content ID deductions. Sometimes content owners claim matches incorrectly and the money is split or held until disputes are resolved. That can sit for months. Always demand a breakdown of Content ID claims and the evidence for each claim.

How To Verify Settlement Sheets Like A Forensic Accountant With Better Taste In Hoodies

If you keep reading you will stop letting people ghost your money. Here is an actionable system to verify payments and catch liars in the act.

Step 1 Ask For The Full Raw Reports

Tell your label or distributor you want the raw DSP remittance reports, not just the summary. Raw reports should include play counts by territory, ISRCs, UPCs, gross revenue, refunds and chargebacks, and the payer details. If a company refuses, that is a red flag. Most legitimate partners will provide that when requested. If they push back ask for the statements in CSV or Excel format. Spreadsheets are your friends.

Template request email

Hi [Name],

Thanks for the payment. For my accounting I need the raw remittance reports that support this payment. Please send the DSP reports in CSV or Excel format that include ISRC, UPC, territory, play counts, gross revenue, reserves, refunds and any deductions. I need reports covering [date range]. Can you send these by [date]?

Thanks,
[Your Name]

Step 2 Match Streams To Statements

Once you have the raw report match the ISRC and play counts to the play counts your own analytics show. Use Spotify for Artists, Apple Music for Artists, and YouTube Analytics. They will not have identical numbers because of different reporting windows, but large discrepancies are suspicious. If a DSP reports far fewer plays than your analytics for the same period ask why. Sometimes plays are attributed to a different territory or a different ISRC. That can be fixed if you push for a metadata correction.

Example math

If Spotify reports 100,000 streams for your track in a month and your distributor statement shows 80,000 streams credited you have a 20,000 stream gap. Multiply that gap by the per stream payout the distributor used to see the missing dollars. If the distributor applies a per stream rate of $0.0035 you have $70 missing. That is not life changing on its own. Multiply that by 12 months and all tracks and you start to see the problem scale.

Step 3 Reconstruct The Payout

Ask for gross revenue numbers for each DSP not just net. Gross means before the distributor or label takes its cut. If you can see the net subscription revenue for the period you can calculate the pool and estimate what your share should be. If they refuse to provide gross numbers ask for the payer's settlement with the distributor or label. Those are the documents where DSPs state exact payments.

Step 4 Verify Deductions With Paper Receipts

If a label deducts promotion or video costs ask for receipts, invoices, vendor names, and dates. Do not accept vague line items like marketing fee or admin costs that add up to thousands of dollars. The contract usually requires that expenses be reasonable and properly documented. If the label says the expense is confidential because of vendor relationships ask for redacted invoices with the cost intact. If they still refuse send a formal audit notice. Most contracts give you audit rights. Use them.

Step 5 Check For Cross Collateralization And Allocations

Cross collateralization should be visible in the settlement ledger. If payables are being applied across releases you will see credits and debits allocated to different UPCs or projects. If you find this happening and your agreement did not clearly specify cross collateral terms you have leverage. Document everything and consult an entertainment lawyer or a royalty auditor.

Step 6 Audit The PRO And Mechanical Statements

PROs and mechanical collection entities have separate systems. Make sure the songwriter splits registered with PROs match your agreements. If a co writer is missing or a publisher is incorrectly listed you will lose money. For mechanical royalties confirm that the MLC or the local collecting agency lists your song and the splits correctly. If they do not, fix the metadata and file a claim. These bodies provide public portals where you can see what is registered. Use them.

How Audits Work And When To Use One

An audit is a formal review of accounting records by a third party or by you with legal leverage to access books and records. Many record deals give the artist limited rights to audit within a timeframe often called the statute of limitations. Typical windows are three to four years. If your contract allows audits use them. Auditors will request documents from labels, DSPs, and other payers. They will reconcile payments and costs and issue a report. Audits cost money but they pay for themselves if the errors are big enough.

Red flags that warrant an audit

• Persistent unexplained reserves or chargebacks
• Major hits with small or no payments to the artist
• Refusal to provide raw DSP reports or invoices
• Recent contract changes that increase deductions without detail

DIY Audit Checklist Before Calling An Auditor

• Collect artist portal analytics for the relevant period from Spotify for Artists and other DSPs
• Request raw remittance reports from your label or distributor
• Gather your contracts and note audit rights and time limits
• List all receipts and invoices the label should have for promotions or manufacturing
• Confirm metadata: ISRC, UPC, songwriter splits, publisher details
• Make note of every discrepancy with dates and amounts

Templates You Can Use Right Now

Formal Audit Demand Email

Subject: Audit Request Under Section [X] of Agreement

Hi [Name],

Under Section [X] of our Agreement I am requesting an audit of the accounting records for the period [start date] through [end date]. Please provide access to the following documents within 14 days.

1. Raw DSP remittance reports in Excel or CSV including ISRC, UPC, territory, play counts, gross revenue, reserves and deductions.
2. Invoices and receipts for any deductions applied against my account during the stated period.
3. Bank deposit records and payer remittance advices showing the gross receipts received for my recordings.
4. Any contracts or invoices with third party vendors related to marketing, manufacturing or distribution covered by our agreement.

If you prefer we can coordinate a mutually agreeable time for an on site inspection or remote data transfer. I expect cooperation in accordance with our agreement and applicable law.

Regards,
[Your Name]

Metadata Correction Request Template

Hi [DSP or Distributor],

Please correct metadata for ISRC [ISRC code] and UPC [UPC code]. Current listing credits the track to [incorrect name] and shows songwriter split of [wrong split]. Correct metadata should be:

Title: [Correct Title]
Artist: [Correct Artist Name]
ISRC: [Correct ISRC]
Writer(s): [Correct writer names and their splits]
Publisher: [Correct publisher details]

Please confirm when the correction is complete and provide updated remittance reports for [date range] to ensure revenue allocation is adjusted.

Thanks,
[Your Name]

How Much Can You Recover

It depends. Small discrepancies mean small recoveries. Large systemic issues and long periods of misaccounting can mean thousands to millions depending on your catalog. Some artists recover six figures after audits. Others recover enough to fund their next album. The point is you are leaving money on the table if you accept summaries without documents and if you assume the company is always honest.

Red Flags That Suggest Fraud Or Gross Misconduct

• Missing ISRCs or conflicting ISRCs for the same track
• Massive reserves that never clear over many quarters
• Repeated refusal to provide raw reports or vendor invoices
• Payments routed to shell companies or unknown bank accounts
• Contracts that allow one party to change terms unilaterally without notice

If you see these you should escalate to a lawyer and consider a forensic audit. Also document everything in writing. If you have DMs, text messages, and emails that show promises or invoices, save them. Contracts are not the only evidence that counts in a dispute.

How To Avoid Getting Into These Messes In The First Place

You cannot avoid all bad actors. You can, however, reduce your risk. Here is a pre sign checklist.

• Get the royalty rate and all deductions in writing
• Insist on audit rights with a practical statute of limitations of at least three years
• Specify metadata ownership and who is responsible for registering ISRCs and splits
• Avoid full cross collateralization or at least limit it to a single project
• Limit exclusivity terms and set clear reversion triggers if the label or distributor does not exploit the recordings within a time frame
• Ask for quarterly accounting not annual statements
• Keep your own copies of masters, session files, and release materials so you can prove ownership and metadata

When To Walk Away From A Deal

If a company demands ownership of your masters in exchange for minimal services or refuses to allow basic transparency in accounting then walk away. Respectable companies will not hide their books. They will not insist on weird fees with no invoices. They will not attempt to lock you into a contract where you cannot audit their statements. Trust your intuition. If the rep keeps saying trust me while refusing to supply proof that you are getting paid fairly that is not a relationship, that is a trap.

Common Questions You Actually Need Answers For

Can I force a label or distributor to show me DSP remittance reports

Yes if your contract gives you the right to audit. If it does not, negotiate that right before signing. If the company is a distributor and you are an independent artist you should demand transparency in writing. Many distributors will provide reports because they know artists will ask. If they refuse you can escalate to a lawyer or move to a distributor that values transparency.

How long should I keep records

Keep everything for at least seven years. Even if your contract’s audit window is three years you might uncover long term patterns that matter. Tax audits, royalty disputes and licensing claims can surface years later. Keep contracts, emails, invoices, analytics exports and bank statements in both cloud and local storage.

Can I reclaim royalties paid to the wrong account

Sometimes. If you have proof that metadata was incorrect and the money went to someone else, you can work with the DSP and the collecting society to re route the royalties. That often requires documentation and cooperation from the party that received the funds. It can be messy but it is possible. The quicker you act the better your chances.

Quick Action Plan You Can Use Today

1. Download your analytics from Spotify for Artists, Apple Music for Artists and YouTube Analytics for the last 24 months.
2. Send the raw remittance report request email to your label or distributor with a 14 day deadline.
3. Check your PRO and mechanical registrations now. Fix metadata if there are typos.
4. If your deal lacks audit rights start negotiating audit language for your next contract. No audit rights equals no recourse.
5. If you suspect fraud consult a royalty auditor or entertainment lawyer. Document all communication in writing before you escalate.

FAQ

What is the difference between a settlement sheet and a royalty statement

A settlement sheet is the raw, detailed ledger from the payer showing itemized transactions like streams, territories, ISRCs, and gross amounts. A royalty statement is often the summarized version sent to you showing net payment after deductions. Always ask for the settlement sheet when you get a royalty statement.

How do DSPs calculate payouts

Most DSPs use a pro rata pool model. They total the revenue for a period then divide by total eligible streams to determine a per stream rate. Your payout is your stream share times that rate. This means per stream values vary by month and by territory. Getting the gross pool numbers helps you sanity check the payout.

What is a royalty audit and how much does it cost

A royalty audit is a review performed by a specialist who reconciles records between payers and payees. Cost varies widely. Expect a few thousand dollars minimum for small catalogs. Many auditors work on a contingency basis taking a percentage of recovered funds which aligns incentives but read the agreement carefully.

What if my contract says no audits

That is a bad clause. Try to negotiate audit rights before signing. If you have already signed look for any alternate clauses that allow inspection or financial reporting. If you suspect misconduct and you have no audit rights consult a lawyer because you may have other legal remedies depending on local laws and the contract specifics.

How do I fix wrong metadata

Contact the DSP or distributor, provide the correct ISRC and UPC and request a metadata correction. Also update registrations with PROs and mechanical collection societies. Keep records of your requests. If distributors delay, escalate in writing and copy your lawyer if needed.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access