Royalty Basing On PPD Instead Of SRLP Without Clarity - Traps & Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

If your record contract says royalties are calculated on PPD instead of SRLP and you did not ask many questions you may be signing away thousands without noticing. Welcome to the music industry school of nails where the math looks simple until labels quietly change what price they base your share on. This guide is for artists who want to understand the difference between PPD and SRLP, spot the sneaky contract tricks, and fight back with practical clauses and tactics that actually work.

Everything here is written in plain language with real life scenarios that will make you laugh and then make you mad. We explain jargon so you can talk to lawyers and not get punched by accountants. You will learn the traps labels use when they say they use PPD, how that often yields less money than SRLP, how digital pricing gets manipulated, and what to negotiate before you sign or after you notice a screw up.

What Do PPD and SRLP Mean

First let us define the acronyms so you can sound smart and dangerous in meetings.

• PPD means Published Price to Dealer. That is the price the record company says it charged the retailer or distributor. In simple cases it is the real wholesale price. In tricky cases it is whatever number the company writes on their internal spreadsheet.
• SRLP means Suggested Retail List Price. That is the sticker price a consumer sees when they shop. Think the price on a streaming store or the retail price on a vinyl sleeve. It is usually higher than PPD.

Why does that matter? When royalties are a percentage of SRLP you generally get more per unit than when royalties are a percentage of PPD. If a contract is unclear and the company uses PPD without clarifying how PPD is set you could be paid significantly less than you expect.

Why Labels Prefer PPD over SRLP

Labels love PPD because it is usually smaller than SRLP. Smaller base means smaller payouts. PPD also gives labels flexibility. They can change the PPD number by creating internal discounts or bundled deals and still say they followed the contract wording. That flexibility is profit in their ledger and loss in your bank account.

Here are real reasons labels push for PPD.

• They control PPD numbers and can lower them retroactively with accounting adjustments.
• PPD lets them apply distributor discounts and promotional allowances that cut the effective price before your percentage is calculated.
• PPD is a cleaner concept for physical sales historically so some legacy contracts default to it while digital pricing got messy later.
• PPD gives labels a justification for paying smaller mechanical royalties for downloads and physical units when the consumer price is higher.

Simple Math Example That Will Make You Scream

Imagine your royalty is 15 percent of the price. This is how it plays out.

• SRLP retail price is ten dollars.
• PPD wholesale price is six dollars.
• Royalty on SRLP at 15 percent is one dollar and fifty cents per unit.
• Royalty on PPD at 15 percent is ninety cents per unit.

That one dollar and fifty cents versus ninety cents difference is sixty cents per unit. Sell ten thousand units and sixty cents becomes six thousand dollars. That is dinner, studio time and a flight to a festival if the math had been in your favor.

How PPD Is Manipulated in the Real World

Labels use many tactics to make PPD smaller. Some are subtle. Some are bold. Here are the ones you must recognize.

Distributor Discount Games

A label may define PPD as the price after a standard distributor discount of up to 40 percent. If they can claim the distributor gets that much discount even on direct store downloads they reduce the PPD. Some agreements let the label choose the discount amount within a range without proof. That is a red flag.

Bundling and Free Goods

Sell a vinyl with a free t shirt and call the PPD the combined price less a generous deduction for the t shirt. Or bundle an album with a concert ticket and allocate most of the ticket value away from the album. The labeled PPD of the album drops and so does your royalty.

Promotional Pricing and Temporary SRLP Cuts

Retailers run sales and streaming services run promotions. If the contract uses SRLP but allows the label to claim the sale is promotional and not countable or allows a reserve against returns they can exclude those sales from the SRLP pool or apply an adjusted PPD.

Digital Special PPD

Digital stores and streaming services sometimes have a notional wholesale price for accounting. Labels have been known to create a separate lower PPD for digital downloads and streams while keeping SRLP intact for CDs and vinyl. It is called price differentiation and it eats your streaming money.

Retroactive Adjustments

Some companies reserve the right to change PPD later because of chargebacks or refunds. If they lower PPD later they issue negative entries on your royalty statement and you end up owing them money or having your future statements reduced.

Common Contract Clauses That Hide The Trap

Contracts use certain phrases that look normal but hide the PPD trap. Watch for these and never sign without fixing them.

• Any clause that says royalties are calculated on PPD without defining PPD in explicit monetary or operational terms.
• Provisions that allow the company to determine PPD in its sole discretion.
• Language that permits deductions from PPD for packaging or promotional expenses without limits.
• Reserve provisions that allow the label to withhold a percentage of income for returns or chargebacks with no time limit or schedule of release.
• Clauses that mix net receipts and PPD or that say royalties are based on net receipts which the company equates to a PPD they invent.

How This Plays Out with Streaming

Streaming is messy because service payouts are not unit sales. But labels still want to translate streams into a PPD equivalent to calculate artist royalties. Here is how that can go wrong.

Label Picks a Per Stream Value

Labels sometimes assign a per stream dollar value and call that the PPD equivalent. If that number is low you get less. If the company chooses the value unilaterally you are at their mercy.

Bucket Payments into Different PPD Classes

Some companies split income into categories like premium subscriptions, ad supported streams, and user uploaded content and assign different PPDs to each. They then use the lowest PPD on the largest bucket and get away with paying minimal royalties.

Reserve and Recoup From Streaming

If your contract allows recoupment from all income streams and the label uses a conservative PPD on streams they will claim your advances are still recouped while you collect almost nothing.

Red Flag Checklist You Can Use Immediately

Before you sign read your contract with these items underlined and circled in red pen. If any of them are present do not sign without negotiation.

• PPD is undefined or defined as any price the company deems appropriate.
• SRLP appears but only as suggested and subject to company adjustment.
• The company can set PPD in its sole discretion.
• There is no audit right or the audit window is absurdly short.
• Reserve against returns or chargebacks with no clear schedule for release.
• Cross collateralization allows recouping of unrelated costs from your royalties.
• Digital sales and streams are not specifically addressed or are lumped into net receipts without definition.

Real Life Scenarios And How They Feel

Story one

You sign a deal with a small label excited about vinyl and a marketing push. The contract says royalties are 12 percent of PPD. You later discover one hundred vinyl units sold at twelve dollars retail. The label claims PPD was four dollars after a twenty five percent distributor discount and a packaging allowance. You receive forty eight dollars for one hundred units. You want to cry. The label wants you to be grateful for exposure.

How to handle this

• Ask for a written breakdown of how PPD was calculated for each sale type.
• Demand a floor PPD for physical units tied to SRLP so you get at least a minimum per unit.
• Negotiate an escalation so the royalty percent rises if SRLP exceeds a certain threshold.

Story two

A streaming service pays big money to the label for a featured playlist. The label allocates the income across many tracks but uses a tiny per stream PPD for your track because it was not the headliner. Your bank account does not match the headline news the label posted on social media.

How to handle this

• Insist on a clause requiring that playlist and sync income be accounted separately with transparent splits.
• Ask for minimum unit valuations for featured placements.
• Negotiate a bonus clause for playlist features that pays a fixed amount above any PPD calculation.

What To Ask For In The Contract

Do not be cute about this. Use plain demands. If they resist they either expect you to be weak or they intend to keep the wiggle room. Here are practical clauses to push for.

Define PPD Precisely

Sample language to propose

PPD means the actual amount invoiced by the company to an unrelated retail dealer for the product in the relevant territory excluding any value added tax sales tax returns or similar governmental charges and excluding any distributor discount in excess of X percent that is documented with third party invoices.

Explanation

Put maximum numbers on distributor discounts and require documentation. Make VAT and tax explicit exclusions. This forces the label to use real invoices if they claim low PPD.

Minimum SRLP Floor

Sample language to propose

If the SRLP for the product in a territory exceeds the PPD floor the royalty shall be calculated on SRLP or at the minimum on a PPD floor of Y dollars whichever is greater.

Explanation

This gives you a safety net so the label cannot reduce PPD beneath a floor if the retail price is healthy.

Separate Accounting For Special Income

Sample language to propose

Income from playlist features promotional campaigns direct licensing or any special marketing payment shall be accounted separately and shall not be included in the calculation of PPD based royalties without the artist's prior written consent.

Explanation

Make playlist money and other special fees transparent and off limits for default PPD calculations.

Time Bound Reserves

Sample language to propose

Any reserve against returns or chargebacks shall be limited to X percent of gross receipts for a period not to exceed 18 months after the applicable accounting period. Any funds remaining in reserve after that period shall be released to the artist within 60 days.

Explanation

Labels love unlimited reserve windows. Put clear caps and timelines so money does not get stuck in a vault forever.

Audit Rights And Access To Invoices

Sample language to propose

The artist shall have the right to audit the company's books and records relating to the calculation of PPD and SRLP once every 12 months at the artist's cost and the company shall provide copies of all relevant third party invoices and distribution agreements upon request. If underpayment is found the company shall reimburse audit costs and interest at X percent per annum.

Explanation

If you cannot see the invoices that prove PPD you cannot challenge the number. Audit rights and the right to actual invoices are your sword.

Negotiation Tactics That Work

Negotiation is not a cage fight unless the label makes it one. Use these tactics to be effective without burning bridges.

• Ask for defined terms not promises. Labels can promise to be fair but the devil is the definition.
• Trade concessions. If they resist a PPD floor offer a limited cap on SRLP royalty increases or agree to performance based escalators that reward both sides.
• Use examples. Ask them to run hypothetical statements on three scenarios including a big retail sale a streaming windfall and a discounted sale. See what numbers you get.
• Bring a savvy manager or entertainment lawyer. You want someone who knows what to ask for and can speak numbers fluently.
• Ask for a goodwill transparency clause for the first 24 months. If they refuse that is a signal they plan to adjust numbers later.

How To Audit A Royalty Statement Without Getting Annoyed

Auditing sounds scary and expensive but you can do a first pass yourself before hiring anyone. Here is a quick audit checklist you can run in an hour if you have the statement.

• Check units sold against streaming metadata and distributor reports. Do they match?
• Look for large negative adjustments. Big negative entries are red flags for chargebacks.
• Compare SRLP on store pages to the SRLP the company reports. If they differ ask for explanation.
• Check the PPD values used for each sale type against distributor invoices where possible.
• Spot bucket allocations. If most income is allocated to the lowest paying bucket ask why.

If something smells wrong escalate to a lawyer or a forensic accountant. Small audits often pay for themselves if they reveal systemic underpayment.

What To Do If You Discover You Were Short Changed

Findings like missing money are upsetting. Here is a calm practical plan of action.

1. Gather your documents. Royalty statements press releases distributor reports store receipts and emails about pricing.
2. Request an explanation in writing. Ask how PPD was calculated and for supporting invoices and distribution agreements.
3. If the answer is incomplete request a formal audit per your contract. If you do not have audit rights negotiate them now or go to small claims if sums are small and you are confident.
4. If the label refuses to cooperate consult an attorney with experience in record contracts. A demand letter often fixes things.
5. Consider public pressure if legal avenues are slow and you have leverage. Social posts and industry allies can move money faster than legal notices sometimes but use this carefully.

International Stuff You Should Know

Different countries have different retail channels and VAT rules. PPD calculations can change wildly across territories. Here are quick rules of thumb.

• VAT and sales tax typically should be excluded from PPD calculations. If your contract does not say so ask for exclusion language.
• Distribution models vary. Some territories rely on major retailers with tight margins. Know the local SRLP and PPD norms so you can push for proper floors.
• Currency conversion matters. Ask for a defined currency for accounting and a clear conversion method for foreign receipts.

Quick Glossary And Real World Analogies

Music contracts are full of shorthand that can make your eyes glaze over. Here are simple definitions plus a real world image so you remember.

• PPD Published Price to Dealer. Think wholesale price the store paid behind the scenes for bulk inventory.
• SRLP Suggested Retail List Price. Think the price on the shelf that shoppers see and that looks shiny and important.
• Reserve Money the label holds back in case of returns or refunds. Imagine a shopkeeper keeping cash in a jar until they are sure customers will not return items.
• Net receipts Money left after certain deductions. It is like being paid for a pie after someone took the biggest slice and charged for the box and delivery.
• Cross collateralization Using income from one project to pay debts from another. It is like being told your concert t shirt sales can pay for a billboard from a separate project.

Sample Email Template To Request PPD Breakdown

Copy paste this and send it if you suspect shenanigans. Keep the tone calm and businesslike.

Hello [Accounting Contact Name],

I am reviewing the royalty statement for period [period]. Please provide a written breakdown showing how PPD was calculated for each sale type and territory. Include copies of third party invoices or distribution agreements that support the distributor discounts and any promotional adjustments applied.

Also please confirm whether any reserves or chargebacks related to these statements are still outstanding and provide the schedule for release.

Thanks in advance for your prompt response.

Best
[Your Name]

How Much Leverage Do You Actually Have

Not every artist can force a major label into a full rewrite of their contract. However every artist has leverage of some kind. Here are common levers and when to use them.

• New or unsigned artist with little leverage. Push for transparency clauses and audit rights rather than large percentage changes. Get a minimum floor if possible.
• Growing artist signing with an indie. You can demand clearer PPD definitions and time bound reserves. Indis often prefer fair relationships and will negotiate.
• Established artist with touring and an audience. You have leverage for advances and better royalty bases. Use your track record to secure SRLP basis or guaranteed per unit minimums.
• Catalogue owner negotiating re release. You can insist on retroactive accounting changes and audit access for previous periods as a condition of any new deal.

When To Walk Away

Sometimes the contract stinks and no amount of negotiation will fix the fundamentals. Walk away if the label insists on sole discretion over PPD or refuses any meaningful audit rights. Do not be romantic. Exposure means nothing if your royalty statements are an accounting lie.

FAQ

What if my contract only says royalties are a percentage of PPD and does not define PPD

That is a big red flag. Without a definition the company can choose any price they like. Insist on precise definition of PPD and require documentary proof such as invoices. If the company refuses require a minimum PPD floor tied to SRLP.

Can labels retroactively change PPD and charge me back

Some contracts permit retroactive adjustments for chargebacks or returns. That can result in negative entries on future statements. Limit this with a time bound reserve clause and require supporting documentation for any retroactive adjustment. If the contract allows unlimited retroactive changes that is risky.

Does SRLP always mean I get more money

Not always. SRLP usually yields a higher calculation base but labels can exclude promotional sales from SRLP accounting or reduce SRLP via price adjustments. However negotiating SRLP basis or a floor is usually better for artists than an undefined PPD basis.

If I find underpayments what are my options

Request documentation ask for an audit and consult a lawyer experienced in record accounting. For small sums small claims may work. For larger amounts a demand letter or litigation might be necessary. Public pressure can help but use it carefully to avoid burning bridges.

Are streaming royalties calculated on PPD or SRLP

Streaming accounting is complex. Some contracts translate streaming income into a PPD equivalent. Others pay separate shares for master and composition. Make sure digital income is addressed explicitly in your contract and that playlist and promotional income is accounted for separately and transparently.

What is a reasonable distributor discount cap to ask for

Negotiable but asking for documentation for any discount more than 20 to 30 percent is reasonable. If a contract allows a 50 percent discount without proof challenge it. Ask for real invoices or set a cap that requires prior approval for larger discounts.

Should I pay for an audit myself

Initial review you can do yourself. If you see real issues hire an expert. Put audit costs back on the company if you find underpayment. That is a common contractual remedy. Do not spend thousands before you have a clear sign of systematic problems.

Can I negotiate a hybrid clause that uses SRLP for physical and PPD for digital

Yes and that is often a practical compromise. But require clear definitions for both and put minimum floors for digital conversions. Ask for separate accounting for downloads streams and sync payments so nothing gets swept into a low paying PPD bucket.

How often should I get royalty statements

Quarterly statements are common for digital income. Semiannual or annual for physical can happen but try to negotiate at least semiannual reporting. The faster you get statements the quicker you can spot problems.

Is this advice legal advice

No. This guide explains common industry practice and negotiation tactics. Consult a qualified entertainment lawyer before signing any contract or taking legal action.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access