Publishing Deal Assignment Of Copyright You Can't Reverse - Traps & Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

Warning You could sign away the songs you wrote while you were hungry, broke, or drunk on applause. This guide is for songwriters producers and bands who want to survive the publishing jungle without selling their souls. It explains what an assignment of copyright actually does how it can become effectively impossible to undo and which contract language and scams will bury your income for decades.

We keep the legal stuff readable and give real life scenarios you can relate to. Everything here assumes the reader wants control of their music career and does not enjoy being ghosted by a lawyer five years after a bad deal.

What Is Assignment Of Copyright

Assignment of copyright is when a songwriter transfers some or all of their ownership rights in a composition to another party. The party who transfers is the assignor and the party who receives is the assignee. It is not the same as a license. A license lets someone use your song under conditions you set. Assignment hands over ownership rights like your publishing share to someone else. If you assign the copyright in the composition you may lose the legal power to control licensing distribution collection and importantly the future transfer of that song.

Key Terms Explained

• Copyright The legal right that gives creators control over copying distribution public performance and adaptations of a work.
• Publisher A company or person that exploits songs for income in exchange for a share of revenue. Publishers pitch songs for sync licensing collect royalties and handle registrations.
• Admin deal Short for administration deal. The publisher collects royalties and registers songs for a fee while you keep ownership.
• Work for hire A legal concept where the employer is the legal author. If a song is a work for hire the original creator may never own the copyright.
• PRO Performing rights organization. Organizations like ASCAP BMI and SESAC in the United States collect performance royalties for songwriters and publishers. We explain more about them later.

Exclusive Assignment Versus Non Exclusive Assignment

An exclusive assignment means the assignee has sole ownership rights to the assigned interest. Non exclusive assignment is rare for full copyright and usually means you are assigning certain uses while keeping others. Most sketchy deals will try to lobby for exclusive worldwide assignment in perpetuity. That sentence should make you run to a lawyer.

Exclusive assignment can be total and absolute or limited by term territory or purpose. For example a publisher might ask for exclusive publishing rights worldwide for the term of copyright. That means the publisher controls licensing and receives publishing income for the full statutory life of the work plus the given term. If you accept that you will likely never see those rights again unless the contract includes a reversion or termination mechanism.

Work For Hire Is The Nuclear Option

When a composition is designated work for hire in the contract or meets the legal criteria it becomes owned by the party who commissioned it from the moment of creation. In practice that means a label an employer or a producer who hires writers can become the copyright owner. In the United States work for hire removes the songwriter from paper ownership and from statutory termination rights. Many musicians have lost catalogs this way because they signed a statement on a piece of paper calling a demo a work for hire without realizing the consequences.

Why Some Assignments Feel Irreversible

There are several reasons a legal transfer of copyright feels impossible to reverse in practical terms even if you might have a theoretical legal path.

• No reversion clause Contracts that give rights in perpetuity with no return trigger leave you dependent on the assignee to voluntarily reassign or to reach a settlement.
• Large advances Recoupable advances create a financial barrier. You cannot get the rights back until the advance and associated costs are paid back. Publishers often structure recoupment to last decades.
• Work for hire Grants no statutory termination rights in some jurisdictions. Once the work is labeled a work for hire the creator is erased on paper.
• Catalog sales When a publisher sells your catalog to a third party the new owner may be uncooperative. Buyers rarely give things back because they bought a revenue stream.
• Lack of resources Starting a multi year legal battle costs money and time. Many artists give up because litigation is expensive and emotionally draining.

Common Traps And Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

Remember that people who sound helpful do not always have your best interest at heart. Here are the most common traps disguised as opportunities.

Fake Publisher That Wants You To Assign The Copyright For Registration

Scenario: A company emails saying they will register your songs with PROs for a small fee. They ask you to sign an assignment so they can do the paperwork. You sign. Later you realize the company collects the publisher share and keeps it forever.

Red flag: Any service that asks for a transfer of ownership in exchange for registration or basic admin services is scamming you. Registration and admin do not require assignment. You can sign a limited administration agreement that leaves ownership with you and gives the admin party a commission. Always insist on an admin agreement that is non exclusive and limited in term.

Low Ball Catalog Buyouts From Predatory Companies

Scenario: You get a call offering a lump sum to buy your future publishing for life. You take the money. Five years later your song is in a hit and the buyer makes far more than what they paid you. You have no share of that windfall.

Red flag: If the offer is less than a rough present value of future earnings figure you are likely underpriced. Use an industry rep or lawyer to evaluate. Most catalog buys are fine when you want an exit but predatory offers to starving artists are common. Be skeptical when the buyer pressures you to sign fast.

Administration Deal Disguised As Full Publishing

Scenario: A publisher sends an administration contract that says they will be your admin but then quietly the contract has a clause that assigns publisher ownership to them if you do not meet certain performance metrics. You just signed something that can convert into full ownership transfer without a clear trigger.

Red flag: Watch for conversion clauses that kick in based on nebulous conditions like "substantial promotional activity." Insist that admin deals stay as admin deals. Any transfer to publisher ownership must be a separate explicit voluntary choice you make later.

Pay To Play Publishing Deals

Scenario: A company offers a publishing review meeting. They say you must pay an upfront fee or buy services to be considered. If you pay they put pressure on you to sign a contract that includes assignment clauses.

Red flag: Legit publishers do not require payment to read songs. If there is a legitimate production service or sync pitching fee it should never come with a requirement to assign ownership. Treat pay to play as suspect and get a lawyer to read anything you sign after paying money.

Excessive Admin Commission With Hidden Fees

Scenario: An admin agreement looks fair with a 15 percent commission. Later you discover additional processing fees a split of sub publishing income and charges for registrations that eat away at returns. The contract also gives them the right to collect and hold funds without timely accounting.

Red flag: Total all the fees and watch for double dipping. Ask for a net payment provision that shows the exact split after fees. Demand audit rights and short accounting intervals. The best admins are transparent and give you monthly or quarterly statements.

Work For Hire Clauses In Demo Sessions

Scenario: You record demos with a studio and sign a basic studio agreement. Buried in the terms is a work for hire clause. Suddenly the studio claims ownership of the compositions because they paid for the session.

Red flag: Never sign any studio or hire agreement that calls your songs work for hire. Insist that the studio only gets a license to the recordings not the composition. Keep intellectual property separate from technical service agreements.

Real Life Horror Stories That Should Make You Furious

These are anonymized but painfully common.

• A band sold their early catalog to pay for a tour van and later saw a song used in a blockbuster film. The band saw none of the sync income.
• A solo songwriter signed a deal with a small publisher who registered as publisher with the PRO and pocketed half the public performance money because the writer had not set up a publisher entity.
• A session musician was told to sign a release to be credited. The release converted the composition into a work for hire and the musician lost ownership of melodies they created in the studio.

If any of these sound familiar we will cover recovery steps shortly.

How To Spot Red Flags In Any Contract

If you see any of these clauses slow down and call someone who knows the terrain.

• Worldwide forever assignment with no reversion or termination clause
• Work for hire language covering compositions or ambiguous work created by you
• Automatic conversion from admin to full publishing on vague triggers
• Recoupable expenses not tied to specific receipts or with unlimited admin fees
• Assigning termination rights away or attempting to waive statutory termination rights
• Audit windows longer than three years and accounting frequency of annual or worse
• Any clause that requires you to sign away future works without separate approval

Clauses You Should Insist On Before Signing Anything

You can push for simple protections that preserve your future. Here are practical clauses and plain language you can ask for.

Reversion Clause That Triggers Automatically

Ask for a clause that returns rights to you after a defined time or after a revenue threshold. For example a reversion after ten years or after the publisher fails to generate a minimum amount of net income in a rolling three year period. Make the reversion automatic and not dependent on publisher consent.

Clear Term And Territory Language

Limit the term to a defined period such as five to ten years with a renewal option. Limit territory to specific markets if you want that. Avoid worldwide in perpetuity language. The shorter the term the more bargaining power you have in future negotiations.

Non Exclusive Admin Option First

Offer an admin deal with a competitive commission and a short term. This lets you test the publisher without giving ownership. Reserve exclusive publishing discussions until you have measurable results.

Audit Rights And Frequent Accounting

Ask for quarterly accounting or at worst semi annual statements. Insist on independent audit rights at reasonable intervals and that audit costs are borne by the publisher if material errors are found. Limit the audit look back window to three years unless fraud is suspected.

No Work For Hire On Compositions

Insert explicit language that the publisher or any service provider will not claim work for hire status over the composition or any creative element without a separate written agreement signed after negotiation.

Termination And Statutory Rights Preservation

Do not agree to waive statutory termination rights without independent legal counsel. In the United States authors have in many cases a statutory right to terminate transfers after a statutory period under the copyright law. Some contract language attempts to assign those termination rights to the publisher. That can be illegal or unenforceable in some jurisdictions. Still do not sign away your ability to exercise statutory rights.

Clear Definitions Of What A Song Is

Define songs works and compositions precisely. Avoid vague catch all language like all works now or later created. If you plan to write on collaboration calls include an exception for songs created outside the publisher relationship.

Cap On Recoupment And Clear Expense Definitions

Make advances recoupable only from the publisher share and not the writer share. Require receipts for expenses and set a cap on overhead and administrative charges. Prevent double dipping where the same expense is charged to the writer and to the publisher share.

Steps To Take Before You Sign Anything

This is your pre signature checklist. It takes a few hours and could save you decades of lost income.

1. Read the entire contract out loud to a sober friend with good listening skills. If you stumble you found confusing language.
2. Highlight any clause that creates irrevocable or perpetual rights transfer. Ask for clarification.
3. Check whether your PRO registration will be affected. Confirm that you maintain your writer share and decide who will register as the publisher.
4. Ask for an admin only option for a trial term. If the publisher refuses ask why.
5. Consult an entertainment lawyer or an experienced publishing consultant. They will spot transfer traps and conversion mechanisms fast.
6. Negotiate reversion and audit language before signing not after. Contracts are easier to change before they are finalized.

If You Already Signed What Can You Do

Not all is lost. Options depend on the contract terms the exact legal regime and whether the deal included work for hire.

Termination Under United States Law Section 203

If you transferred copyright in the United States you may have a statutory right to terminate that transfer under section 203 of the Copyright Act. Termination windows allow authors or their heirs to reclaim rights after 35 years from the date of transfer with a five year window for notice. There are strict notice requirements and timing rules. Works classified as work for hire do not qualify for termination in the same way. Also transfers made more than 35 years ago might fall under different rules under section 304. Do not try to do this without a qualified copyright attorney. Missed windows can be fatal to your claim.

Review Whether The Transfer Was Valid

Some transfers were obtained by fraud coercion or misrepresentation. Contracts signed under duress or lacking consideration can be challenged. Also check whether the party had authority to demand a work for hire designation. A party representing themselves as your employer when they are not could be in trouble.

Negotiate A Buy Back Or Amendment

Sometimes the pragmatic path is negotiation. Offer a buy back payment or propose a split that restores some control. Publishers and buyers are businesses. They will sometimes accept reasonable offers if the purchase price originally undervalued the work and the market changes can make negotiation attractive.

Public Pressure And Reputation

If a company is acting in bad faith public pressure social media and industry allies can sometimes influence a pragmatic settlement. This is risky and can escalate into litigation. Use it carefully and with counsel.

How PROs Factor Into This Mess

PROs like ASCAP BMI SESAC in the United States and their equivalents worldwide collect public performance royalties for writers and publishers. If you sign away your publisher share the assignee registers with the PRO and collects the publisher portion of performance income. That is why some shady parties target writers who do not have a publisher entity. If you keep your writer share you still get half of the performance income but you will be blocked from receiving the publisher share that often represents a significant portion of catalog income.

Pro tip: Always make sure you and the publisher are registered correctly with your PRO. Check splits on each song and confirm which entity is listed as publisher. If a publisher refuses to register you as the writer publisher in a manner that reflects the actual split do not sign or get legal help fast.

Smart Deal Alternatives To Full Assignment

No one is arguing you should never sign anything. Publishing companies can add value. Here are cleaner options that preserve your future while letting a publisher work their magic.

• Administration agreement Short term non exclusive with a clear commission and audit rights.
• Co publishing deal You give up part of the publisher share in exchange for services while retaining some publishing ownership.
• Sub publishing only For international exploitation where a foreign partner handles territory specific registrations for a commission.
• Split agreement per song Sign deals song by song rather than assigning entire future catalogs.
• Option clause with fair triggers An option to negotiate exclusive publishing if certain transparent milestones are met with fair market valuations.

Negotiation Scripts You Can Use

Use these blunt but polite phrases when a publisher tries to steamroll you.

• I am happy to discuss an administration agreement first. I want to test the partnership before transferring ownership.
• Please limit the term to ten years with an automatic reversion if the song does not generate X amount over a rolling three year period.
• I will not sign any work for hire language for compositions created by me. I can license the recordings for the session if needed.
• I need quarterly accounting and audit rights if numbers are off by more than 5 percent. The audit will be at your expense if errors are found.

When To Call A Lawyer And How To Pick One

Call a lawyer before you sign any clause that transfers ownership permanent or temporary. Good entertainment lawyers can read a contract in minutes and tell you whether it is life changing. You want someone who specializes in publishing copyright and has worked with songwriters and publishers. Ask for references and for past deal examples. A lawyer is an investment not a luxury.

Prevention Plan Every Musician Should Implement Today

1. Create a basic songwriter entity like an LLC or publishing company so you can register as your own publisher with your PRO. It makes predatory collection harder.
2. Keep clean records of creation dates session files and demo notes. If ownership is disputed documentation helps.
3. Never sign a work for hire or assignment clause in a service contract. Keep IP clauses separate and negotiate them as distinct agreements.
4. Educate band members partners and collaborators about splits and get agreements in writing before a release or sync opportunity.
5. Keep a limited set of trusted advisors. Do not let people who want a finder fee negotiate your contract alone.

FAQ

Can I ever get my copyright back after assignment

Possibly. In the United States you may have a statutory termination right after 35 years under section 203 for many transfers that are not work for hire. You may also negotiate a buy back or show that the transfer was invalid due to misrepresentation or fraud. Each case depends on the contract details and the facts. Talk to a lawyer.

Is work for hire the same everywhere

No. Work for hire rules vary by country. The United States has a narrow concept for commissioned works and works created by employees in the scope of employment. Other countries may have stronger moral rights and different rules that make work for hire harder to claim. Always check local law.

What percentage should an admin take

Typical admin commissions range from 10 to 20 percent. Top tier admin services may charge less. Anything above 25 percent should raise questions unless they provide significant global sub publishing and promotional value. Watch for additional hidden fees.

Can a publisher force me to sign away termination rights

Some contracts attempt to assign an author s statutory termination rights to the publisher. In some jurisdictions that attempt may be void or unenforceable. Do not rely on hope. Insist on language that preserves your legal rights and get counsel.

How do I know if a company is a real publisher or a scam

Check their track record references and whether they are registered with PROs. Ask for recent deals and contact past clients. If they demand ownership for basic admin tasks or charge pay to play fees walk away.

What if my band split up and members fight over publishing

Get a split agreement in writing early. If conflicts arise later mediation or arbitration clauses help resolve disputes without destroying the catalog. Keep split percentages documented and consistent with registrations at PROs and distributors.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access