Producer Points With No Cap Or Recoup Order - Traps & Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

Yes this is about your points. The tiny little percentage on a record that somehow buys bread and regret. If you produce songs for a living you need to know what producer points are and how labels or artists can quietly turn them into a long term income leak. This guide explains the legal smoke and mirrors and gives you battle ready fixes. You will learn industry speak broken into plain English, true to life scenarios, negotiation scripts you can steal, contract language you must insist on and a checklist you can use before you sign anything.

Everything here is written for busy producers and musicians who would rather make music than read legal textbooks. Where there is an acronym we explain it. Where there is a trick we show the math. Where there is a negotiation weakness we hand you a line that does not sound like submission. If you want to keep your points and not hand them away to the first corporate fog machine that smiles at your demo you are in the right place.

What Are Producer Points

Producer points are a percentage of the revenue generated by the master recording. The master recording is the actual final recorded song or album that is licensed to streaming platforms, sync licenses and physical sales. When someone says two points they usually mean two percentage points of the master side income. If the master earns money the producer receives that percent according to the agreement.

Producer points are often called points on the master or points on the record. They are not the same as publishing. Publishing refers to songwriting and copyright ownership of the composition. Publishing splits pay out to songwriters and publishers when a song is streamed, performed or licensed. Producer points are about the recording itself. Producers can and often should have both a producer royalty and a publishing split, but those are separate revenue streams.

What Does No Cap Mean

No cap means unlimited recoupment or unlimited potential clawback against what would otherwise be producer earnings. When a contract or a deal memo says that points are subject to recoupment with no cap it often means that any advances or costs the label or artist claims can be recovered forever from the producer royalty stream. Without a cap the label could keep reclaiming money from your points long after a record is old enough to need a walker.

What Is Recoup Order

Recoup order is the order in which income gets paid out to creditors and contributors after revenue arrives. Imagine revenue is a cake and recoup order decides who gets the first slice. If a label puts itself first it recovers recording costs marketing costs video costs and advances before it pays producers. If a producer is behind in the recoup order the cake can disappear before you are allowed a single crumb.

Recoup order is critically important. Labels and artists can set recoup order so that producers get paid only after all label costs and artist recoupment are satisfied. That lowers the effective value of your points and can mean long lag times before earnings hit your bank account.

Common Trap Types

Here are the most common scams and traps you will encounter when producer points or recoup order appear in a deal.

• Points are recoupable with no cap. The label says your points will pay back advances and costs forever. Then they recoup production fees twice and charge vague costs to the record account.
• Producer is behind every recoup order. Label and artist recoup first. You are last or not even listed. You do not see money until the label decides to pay artists and everyone else.
• Cross collateralization without consent. Label ties the album to unrelated projects. Your points on one successful single get used to pay for other failures.
• Points sold or assigned without approval. Your share is transferred to a third party to repay loans given to the artist or label.
• Points disguised as non recoupable but recoupable in small print. They sell you a friendly line then bury language that allows recoupment from every revenue stream.
• No audit rights or limits on audit periods. You cannot confirm the label did not invent phantom costs.

Why This Matters Right Now

Streaming and digital licensing blurred a lot of lines. Large tech platforms pay sums that can be small per stream but massive in aggregate. Labels have become increasingly creative about what they call recoupable. They can claim costs for promotion, marketing, packaging, manufacturing plus any service provider they paid for the release. Without strict language a label can recoup a long list of expenses against master revenues and effectively starve your points for years.

Producers are particularly vulnerable because many need cash quickly and are asked to accept points in exchange for reduced upfront fees. That is fine when points are clean and well documented. It becomes a problem when points are on the hook for everything with no cap and a recoup order that leaves you in the docking line behind layers of corporate claims.

Real Life Scenarios

Scenario One: The Forever Recoup

You produce a single for an independent artist. They do not have money so you accept two points and a small fee. The label picks up the single and pays for a video tour and extra marketing. The contract says your points are subject to recoupment with no cap. The single eventually earns $100 000 in master revenue. The label claims $120 000 of recoupable expenses for the single because they added a bunch of overhead items. Your points pay back nothing because the label claims to not be fully recouped. You never received a cent in royalty checks.

Simple math in plain English can save you from this: If you earn two points on $100 000 you should get $2 000 before other contractual cliffs. If the contract lets the label deduct costs first and sets you behind everything else you can be left with zero while a record that performed well funds a label budget line that never expires.

Scenario Two: The Waterfall Swap

You agree to work on an album with an established artist. The label offers three points but says producer royalties are subject to recoup order that places the artist royalty and label recoupment above you. The album goes gold and the artist gets paid massive advances and bonuses. The label applies those against the master account and keeps your points unreleased under the clause that allows the artist take priority. You see statements that say zero due because the artist and label were recouped first.

Recoup order matters more than the number of points if the order places you last. Three points might be worth more than six points if you are paid earlier in the waterfall. The order is the plumbing. If the plumbing is clogged you get wet and nothing flows into your account.

How Labels Make These Clauses Sticky

Labels and managers write contracts with words like recoupable costs net receipts and record account. Those words can be defined broadly. A broad definition may include marketing agency retainers touring support and even negative balance from previous releases. The broadness gives the label flexibility to direct income away from producers. Here are the common tactics.

• Vague definitions. The contract uses terms like net receipts with no formula. That lets the label define the deduction method later in statements.
• Cross collateralization clauses. Income from one record can be used to pay debts from unrelated records.
• Priority clauses for artist and label. Artist advances and recoupable costs get priority over producer royalties.
• Assignment clauses. The label can assign your points to another entity to pay a debt or loan without your consent.
• Reserve account and long reserve periods. Label holds back a portion of royalties as a reserve for returns or chargebacks. Long reserves delay or reduce payments.

Key Contract Terms You Must Understand

Never sign anything until you understand and can explain these terms in plain language and in writing.

Recoupable

Recoupable means an advance or cost is expected to be repaid from future income. If your producer fee is recoupable the label can take that fee back from your points later. Ask what exactly is recoupable and get an itemized list or a cap.

Net Receipts

Net receipts is what the contract calls the money left after deductions. That formula determines how much of the total money is eligible for points. Make sure net receipts is defined narrowly and not left to label accounting discretion.

Cross Collateralization

This allows income from one project to be used to pay debts from another. You do not want that unless you are getting a serious cash incentive that compensates for the risk.

Assignment

Assignment says the label can transfer rights or obligations to another party. You want a clause that prohibits assignment of your points without your written consent.

Audit Rights

Audit rights let you examine the label accounting. Good audit rights specify the frequency of audits who pays and timelines. If you cannot audit you cannot verify what the label claims as recoupable.

Cap or Ceiling

A cap limits the total amount that can be recouped from your points. It is the producer safety net. A cap might be written as a multiple of your fee for example two times the producer fee or a fixed dollar amount.

Practical Clauses To Ask For

Here are clean simple clauses you can propose to limit damage. You can paste these into emails or hand them to your entertainment lawyer as starting points. Replace bracketed text with your specifics.

Cap Clause Example

"Producer royalties shall be subject to recoupment from the producer royalty account only up to a cap of [two times the producer fee] or [USD 20 000] whichever is lesser. No further recoupment shall be made against the producer royalty account after the capped amount has been applied."

Recoupment Source Clause

"All recoupment shall be taken solely from the artist royalty account and shall not be taken from producer royalties or publishing income. Producer royalties shall be paid from gross receipts of the master after deduction only of direct production costs previously agreed in writing."

No Cross Collateralization Clause

"Income attributable to the master shall not be applied to recoup costs or losses attributable to other masters or projects absent the express written consent of the producer."

Assignment Limitation Clause

"The label shall not assign or otherwise transfer the producer royalty without the prior written consent of the producer which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld."

Audit Clause

"Producer shall have the right to audit the label's accounts relating to the master once per 12 month period upon 30 days prior written notice. If any underpayment exceeding five percent of amounts due is discovered the label shall pay the reasonable cost of the audit."

Negotiation Scripts That Do Not Suck

Say this in email or in person. Keep it short and firm. You are not asking permission to be poor.

• "I like the offer. Two points is fair. I need a recoup cap of two times my fee to accept points instead of cash."
• "I accept producer points so long as they are not cross collateralized to other projects. Keeps the math clean."
• "I will sign if the producer royalty is paid from the master account and not offset by artist recoupment or label overhead."
• "I need audit rights and quarterly statements. If I cannot audit then the points do not work for me."

How To Read A Royalty Statement Like A Human Detective

If you do not want to hire an accountant yet you can still spot red flags on royalty statements. Here is the checklist.

• Does the statement show gross receipts and then itemized deductions? If no it is suspicious.
• Is there a large unexplained line for administrative fees or overhead? Ask for detail.
• Are reserves held for an unusually long period? Ask for the reserve policy in writing.
• Do cross project offsets appear? Verify whether that is permitted by your agreement.
• Is there a charge back for previously paid fees? Ask for the documentation that justifies any charge back.

Math That Hits The Face

Let us do a concrete example. You have two points on the master. The master earns $100 000 net receipts for the label after DSP payments licensing and other revenue. With clean accounting two points equals two percent and you get $2 000. Now imagine label claims $150 000 in recoupable costs on the record and places itself and the artist before you in the recoup order. The label says not recouped. You get zero despite the success. That is how recoup order plus no cap kills points.

Another example. You accept one thousand dollars upfront for a beat and two points with no cap. The label recoups $30 000 in marketing. The record earns $10 000 in net receipts in the first year. You see statements that say the label is not recouped and your points do not pay. That is a real world vibe. Your two points are now functionally worthless until they decide otherwise.

Selling Points Or Borrowing Against Them

Sometimes producers sell points to get immediate cash. That can be smart if done carefully. If you sell points to a third party the buyer may want full control. You must document the sale with transfer and assignment language and you must confirm that the sale does not violate the original artist or label agreement. If you borrow against points through a loan agreement make sure the loan does not require assignment without your consent if you default.

Warning. If your contract allows assignment without your consent a lender can force a transfer of your points in the event of default by the artist or label. Keep assignment limited or at least require notice to you so you can protect your interest.

Publishing Versus Producer Points Clarified

Producers sometimes confuse publishing with points. Publishing is songwriting rights. If you wrote melody or lyrics or a hook you are owed a portion of the publishing split. Producer points are about the master. You can have both. If you do not understand who owns what ask the question out loud and get it in writing. Producers are often asked to sign away publishing in exchange for extra points. That can be legitimate but know the value. Publishing is worth money across sync licensing performance and mechanical income. Do not trade it away without math and counsel.

When To Say No

Here are non negotiable red flags. If you see any of these walk or get counsel immediately.

• Points are recoupable with no cap and no definition of recoupable costs.
• No audit rights or your audit costs are always your responsibility no matter the result.
• Assignment allowed without your consent.
• Cross collateralization that is unrestricted and indefinite.
• Statements paid on a timeline that is longer than industry norm with no clear reserve policy.

What To Do If You Are Already Screwed

If you already signed and the contract contains dangerous language do not panic. There are steps you can take.

1. Get your agreement reviewed by an entertainment lawyer or a reputable publishing administrator.
2. Request accounting statements in writing and audit the numbers. Sometimes the threat of an audit corrects sloppy accounting.
3. Seek a negotiated amendment. Offer value in exchange for cleaning the recoupment structure. Labels care about ongoing relationships.
4. Consider selling the points if you need cash and cannot get the label to correct the agreement. Sell to a trusted party and document the sale thoroughly.
5. Track all communications. If you can show the label misled you you may have leverage. Keep emails and messages that show promises that contradict the contract.

Common Misunderstandings Explained

Producer points are the same as songwriting income

No. Producer points are tied to the master recording. Songwriting income is publishing. They are different revenue streams with different collection societies and different payment cadences.

If a label says points are non recoupable I am safe

Not necessarily. Labels can include wording elsewhere that creates indirect recoupment. Always read the full agreement and look for cross references and definitions that negate the non recoupable promise.

Points mean you will get rich later

Maybe. Points are a bet on the record. They can be very valuable for massive hits. They are also worthless if the label or artist buries them under a broad recoupment structure. Make the deal for points only when the terms are clean and the recoup order does not leave you behind the bus.

Checklist Before You Sign

• Is there a clear definition of recoupable costs? If yes read it carefully.
• Is there a cap on recoupment from producer royalties? If no ask for one.
• Does the recoup order place you in a fair position? Ask to be paid from the master account or artist royalties ahead of label overhead.
• Is cross collateralization limited or excluded? If not push back.
• Are assignment rights limited? Do not allow assignment without your consent.
• Do you have audit rights at reasonable intervals and who pays for the audit if underpayment is found? Ideally the label pays reasonable audit costs if underpayment exceeds a small threshold.
• Is publishing separated and recognized? Confirm your splits in writing and how they will be registered with PROs and mechanical licensing bodies.
• Are reserve policies clear? Make sure reserves are industry standard and not permanent withholding.

Who To Consult

Start with an entertainment attorney experienced in producer agreements. If you cannot afford one yet find a reputable music business manager or a union local that offers contract review services. Organizations like the Music Managers Forum or producer collectives sometimes offer legal clinics and pro bono reviews. Use them. Lawyers cost money but signing the wrong contract can cost you orders of magnitude more.

FAQ For Producers

What is a fair cap on recoupment

A fair cap could be two times your producer fee or a fixed dollar cap that reflects your contribution. For example if you took $5 000 as a fee a cap of $10 000 on recoupment from your points would be reasonable. The right cap depends on your leverage and the project. The key is to have a cap rather than an open ended allowance.

Can labels legally recoup from publishing

Only if the contract explicitly allows it. Publishing is a separate income stream and in most standard deals the label cannot take publishing unless you signed publishing away. Keep publishing owned by writers when possible and register splits with performance rights organizations such as ASCAP BMI or SESAC in the United States. Mechanical royalties are collected by agencies like The Mechanical Licensing Collective or third party licensing administrators. Keep publishing clear in writing.

How often should I get statements

Quarterly is standard for many independent deals. Major labels sometimes report twice yearly but you should push for quarterly or at least semi annual statements. The more frequent the statements the fewer surprises and the easier an audit becomes.

Can I demand an upfront advance instead of points

Yes and no. You can ask for more upfront money and fewer points. This may reduce your potential upside but increases immediate cash. If you need cash now trade for cash with a cap on recoupment in writing. If the project looks like a long play prefer clean points and strong audit and cap language.

What is cross collateralization in normal language

Cross collateralization means profits from one project pay for losses from another. For you it can mean your points on a hit single are used to pay for a flop album. Unless you are receiving significant compensation for taking that risk avoid cross collateralization with no limits.

Can I retroactively change a bad clause if the record is already released

Only if the label agrees. You can negotiate an amendment and offer something in return such as a reduction on future fees or exclusive producer rights on the next project. If the label refuses your legal remedies are limited by the original contract. Getting it right before release is always better than trying to fix it later.

Are producer points taxable

Yes. Producer royalties are income and they must be reported. Consult a tax professional in your jurisdiction. If you receive points that later convert to cash matters for taxes differently depending on when you are paid and how you account for advances and fees. Keep records.

What if the artist owes the label money and the label recoups from my points

If the contract allows label recoupment from the master revenue or places producers behind artist recoupment the label can do that. This is why recoup order and no cross collateralization clauses matter. Try to limit recoupment sources to direct master income that is not already spoken for by artist advances.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access