Lifetime Commission With No Tail Schedule - Traps & Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

Quick truth You will meet people who want a cut of your life income and will call it “partnership.” You want career allies. You do not want a legal leech wearing a suit. This guide tells you how to spot the lifetime commission trap, what the scary phrase no tail schedule actually means, and how to walk away or renegotiate without crying into a busted laptop.

Everything here is written for musicians who need practical defenses and negotiation moves that do not sound like a lawyer lecture. We explain every term and acronym. We give real life examples you can relate to. We include contract redlines you can paste into an email when you are sick of vague promises and friendlier than necessary legalese. Read this now so you do not get haunted by royalty payments in 2032.

What is a lifetime commission and why does it scare musicians

A lifetime commission normally means a person or company receives a percentage of your revenue forever. Forever is literal in many contracts. You might sign a manager agreement, consulting deal, or services agreement where the manager claims a commission on income from your music, live shows, merchandising, licensing, and more for the rest of your life. That is the danger. That claim can survive termination if there is no sunset clause or tail schedule. The result is you will keep paying someone for work they stopped doing years ago.

Real life example

Imagine you sign with a manager who helps book your first tour and negotiates a sync on a TV show. The manager leaves or you fire them two years later. Without a sunset clause, they may still be entitled to a 20 percent cut of every future royalty, including money from a viral TikTok use of your older song six years later. You are still paying them on revenue they no longer create. That is the lifetime commission trap.

Key terms explained so you stop nodding like you understand

• Commission A percentage of income paid to a manager agent or representative for services. For managers the market rate is often 15 to 20 percent. For booking agents the standard is usually 10 percent.
• Tail schedule Also called a sunset clause. This is a window of time after termination during which the manager can still claim commission on business they started before termination. Example windows are 6 months 12 months or 24 months. Longer windows are not always bad but must be fair.
• No tail schedule A clause or the absence of a clause that allows perpetual commission with no time limit after termination. That means lifelong cuts unless contract language says otherwise.
• In perpetuity Means forever. If a contract says commissions are in perpetuity you give up the right to stop those payments without additional negotiation.
• Gross versus net Gross means before expenses. Net means after expenses. Managers will prefer gross because it is simpler and usually higher. Learn the difference and negotiate which base their percentage applies to.
• Recoupment When a company or person advances money they may retain future income until the advance is paid back. This reduces the artist revenue that commission percentages apply to.
• Royalties Money paid over time for use of master recordings mechanical royalties performance royalties synchronization fees and streaming royalties. Each of these streams may be carved out or included differently in a contract.
• PROs Performing Rights Organizations. These are ASCAP BMI SESAC in the United States. They collect public performance royalties for songwriters and publishers. PROs are not the same as SoundExchange that collects digital performance royalties for masters on non interactive radio.
• Admin deal A publishing administration agreement where someone collects publishing money for you in exchange for a percentage. This is different from a manager commission but can get wrapped into creative contract language so you pay twice.

Why artists sign lifetime commission deals

Because early stage artists are vulnerable and flattered. You meet someone who says they will change your life. They offer introductions advances or the promise of a major sync and then hand you a contract to sign that needs an attorney. You sign because momentum is intoxicating. Then momentum becomes monthly payments to someone who ghosted you in year three. Here are the common sales tactics.

• The urgency trap They say the opportunity will evaporate if you do not sign now. That is pressure not convenience.
• The golden example They name drop one big placement they landed for someone else and imply they will do the same for you. Past performance is not a guarantee of future hustle.
• The advance carrot They offer a small advance or pay for a session and then require lifetime commission in return.
• The complex contract trap The contract is long full of legal jargon and signed in a friendly vibe. People rely on signing what is in front of them instead of getting it reviewed.

Trap one: No sunset clause or vague tail language

This is the classic. The agent or manager will include language that says they get a commission on any income related to your career for life. The contract will dress it up with phrases like in perpetuity in all territories or for the full term of copyright. Either way you keep paying even after termination.

How it looks in contract language

Example of dangerous phrasing

Manager shall receive twenty percent of all income derived from Artist's career in perpetuity.

Why this is bad

You cannot reasonably fire the manager and stop payments on revenue they are not contributing to. The clause often covers future services like licensing or merchandising even if the manager had nothing to do with securing those deals.

What to negotiate instead

Ask for a clear sunset clause like this

Manager shall be entitled to commissions on Contracts negotiated and substantially performed during the Term for a period of 12 months following termination. After such 12 month period Manager shall have no further right to commissions except as to Contracts entered into prior to termination where Manager's active involvement directly secured such Contract.

Why this is better

You limit the time the manager can collect after termination and retain protection for deals they truly created. You also add a requirement for active involvement so you do not pay for passive introductions years later.

Trap two: Lifetime commission masked through a production or publishing company

Some scammers create a production company or publishing entity and insist you assign parts of your income to that entity. They then control payout and claim they are a separate vendor who deserves additional payment. The outcome looks like you paying the manager twice.

Real life scenario

Your producer is offered a production deal where the manager is the publisher or the manager's company is listed as co writer on the splits. You sign because your track hits. Later you find out split percentages were assigned to the manager entity and you have to pay them commission on top of that percentage.

How to prevent it

• Insist on clear authorship documentation. Do not assign publishing or writer shares unless the person actually wrote or produced the work.
• Refuse assignation of master rights without separate negotiated compensation that you understand in writing.
• Ask for a conflict of interest clause that requires disclosure if the manager or their company will benefit from separate deals.

Trap three: Commission on gross income including third party payments and credits

Gross can be a loaded term. If the contract says commission applies to gross income the manager may get paid on money that is not actually yours or that you only receive after pass through costs. Examples include money that belongs to session musicians advanced booking costs or third party vendor reimbursements.

Example problem

A promoter pays a guarantee to your manager who then pays you. The manager claims commission on the entire guarantee including production costs. You end up with less than you expected.

Negotiation move

Define commission base precisely

Commission shall be calculated on Artist's actual receipts after deduction of third party pass through expenses including but not limited to session musician fees travel advances and production expenses. Commission shall not apply to amounts collected on behalf of third parties.

Trap four: Lifetime commission on publishing and writer income

Publishing income is the money songwriters and publishers receive for use of compositions. Managers may try to claim commission on publishing income in perpetuity. This is problematic because publishing is the artist songwriter property and often remains relevant long after a management relationship ends.

Why this hurts

Publishing income can be the biggest long term revenue stream. If you give up a cut of publishing forever the manager benefits disproportionately as your catalog ages and syncs increase.

What to do

• Keep publishing income separate from management commission. If a manager wants publishing commission it should be explicitly tied to services rendered for the life of the works they directly placed and should not be automatic.
• Use a short tail for publishing related commissions or tie the commission to specific deals the manager secured within a defined timeframe.
• Consider only paying publishing commission if the manager actually performs administration or placements and charge a reasonable fee for that service instead of a forever percentage.

Trap five: Lifetime commission hidden in vague definitions of revenue

Contracts often define revenue broadly as income royalties payments sync fees merchandising sponsorships endorsements licensing and other consideration. That vague language empowers the claimant to include revenue types you would not expect. They can then take a slice of everything.

Example

Your band signs a brand deal for a shoe company. The manager claims commission on the brand fee the band negotiated directly with the brand even though the manager had no role.

Counter strategy

Define covered revenue narrowly

"Manager Commissionable Revenue" shall mean revenue arising directly from Contracts procured by Manager through Manager's direct efforts during the Term. Such revenue shall not include endorsement or other third party deals entered into by Artist without Manager's direct involvement nor shall it include revenue received by Artist for activities unrelated to Manager initiated opportunities.

Trap six: No audit rights or limited audit periods

If a manager is taking money forever you need the right to audit their books to confirm accuracy. Some contracts allow audits only once every few years or at a cost you cannot afford. Others forbid audits entirely. That is not acceptable.

What you need

• Unrestricted audit rights at reasonable intervals. Common language is one audit per year at Artist expense with additional audits at Manager expense if discrepancies exceed 5 percent.
• Right to request supporting documentation for any commission paid including contracts invoices and bank statements.
• A specified process for dispute resolution over accounting disputes including mediation and arbitration if needed.

Trap seven: Lifetime commission plus assignment rights

Some managers include clauses that allow assignment of your contract rights to third parties. Combined with a lifetime commission this can mean your income flows into newly created companies or partners and you keep paying previous parties who sold the rights onward.

Protective language

Prohibit assignment of commissions or require the artist's consent to any assignment

Manager shall not assign its right to receive commissions hereunder without Artist's prior written consent, which shall not be unreasonably withheld. Any assignment without consent shall be void.

What to do before you sign anything

Checklist when someone asks you to sign

• Read the whole document slowly. Do not sign in a coffee shop because it feels intense. You can smell pressure.
• Look for words in perpetuity forever lifetime without limit and similar phrasing. Ask about them immediately.
• Identify the revenue streams covered and ask for examples of income included and excluded.
• Check for sunset clause tail schedule or absence thereof. If missing push for a clear clause with a specific time period.
• Confirm whether the manager must get your consent before assigning publishing or master rights to any third party.
• Ask for audit rights and a documented process for disputes.
• Take a photo and get legal review. An hour with a music attorney can save years of regret.

Negotiation scripts you can use in real life

When the manager says they need to be paid forever because they are investing emotionally say this

I appreciate the support and the energy you bring. I cannot commit to perpetual commissions. I will agree to a fair sunset clause of 12 months for deals you secure during our relationship. That protects both of us and reflects industry norms.

If they say they expect publishing commission forever respond

Publishing rights are songwriter property. I will not give up publishing income in perpetuity. If you perform publishing administration or secure sync placements I will compensate you with a negotiated fee or a commission limited to deals you actively place within 24 months of termination.

How to rewrite a lifetime clause into a fair clause

Bad clause

Manager shall be entitled to twenty percent of Artist's gross income from all sources in perpetuity.

Better clause

Manager shall be entitled to twenty percent of Artist's gross income from Contracts which Manager procured or substantially negotiated during the Term. Following termination Manager shall be entitled only to commissions on such Contracts for a period of 12 months. Manager's entitlement shall require demonstration of direct involvement in procuring the applicable Contract.

Even better clause with examples

For example if Manager introduced Licensee X to Artist and negotiated a sync fee during the Term, Manager shall be entitled to commissions on revenue from that sync for 12 months following termination. If Licensee X later licenses another unrelated composition of Artist without Manager's involvement, no commission shall be due to Manager.

What if you already signed and discover a lifetime clause

Breathe. Contracts can often be renegotiated or bought out. Here is an action plan.

1. Review the contract carefully and identify exact language that creates lifetime obligation.
2. Ask for a full accounting and documentation of deals the manager claims they procured. Demand transparency per your audit rights.
3. Hire a music attorney experienced in manager and label deals. They can calculate a buyout number and negotiate on your behalf.
4. Consider a lump sum buyout that removes the lifetime obligation. It is often possible to buy out future commissions for a multiple of recent yearly commissions.
5. Negotiate a restructured deal that limits tail length and removes lifetime language. Offer incentive based compensation for future placements instead of a percentage forever.
6. If the manager refuses and you have strong evidence of misrepresentation or duress consider litigation. This is last resort but sometimes necessary.

How to estimate a reasonable buyout

Buyouts are case by case. If a manager takes 20 percent of your income and you average 50 000 per year of commissionable revenue you might expect a buyout multiple of 2 to 4 times annual commission. That means a ballpark of 20 000 to 40 000 depending on the strength of the manager's claim and their willingness to negotiate.

Why a multiple not infinite math

Managers often prefer ongoing commissions as passive income. They may accept a guaranteed lump sum smaller than the infinite expected value because they prefer immediate cash. Use that preference to negotiate.

How to structure fair manager agreements instead

Industry common sense but not law:

• Term length reasonable like 12 to 36 months with defined renewal terms.
• Commission rate fair 15 to 20 percent for managers depending on services and location.
• Sunset clause 6 to 24 months after termination depending on artist stage and manager role. 12 months is very common.
• Clear definition of commissionable revenue and examples of excluded income.
• Audit rights and transparent accounting at least semi annual statements.
• No automatic claims on publishing unless manager actually creates or administers publishing and then compensation is limited to that service.
• Termination for cause and for convenience clauses with clear notice periods. For convenience means either party can end with notice. For cause means specific breaches allow immediate termination.

Suggested clause to include for clarity

"Commissionable Income" means income received directly by Artist and not money passed through to third parties. Commissionable Income excludes session fees remitted to session musicians or other third parties, third party vendor costs, and any advances or reimbursements not retained by Artist. Manager's commission shall be calculated on Artist's net receipts after allowable deductions and shall not exceed twenty percent unless otherwise mutually agreed in writing.

How agents and lawyers differ from managers and why that matters

Booking agents typically take 10 percent of live performance fees. They are often licensed by state rules and have specific agent codes. Lawyers are paid by fees not a commission on your career. A manager handles overall strategy career development and connections and takes a commission. The different roles mean different standards for what is acceptable.

Do not let a manager pretend to be an agent or lawyer to justify taking additional rights or commissions. Contracts should make roles and compensation clear. If someone offers to be everything for you ask for separate agreements for distinct services with separate compensation so you can hold them accountable for each job.

Red flags to leave immediately

• Language that says the manager will receive commissions in perpetuity on all your income worldwide.
• Requests that you assign publishing master writing or outright ownership of songs as a condition of management.
• Refusal to provide written statements of the deals they claim to have made for you.
• Pressure to sign now with verbal promises of future work in lieu of contract changes.
• No audit rights or refusal to allow any accounting verification.

Final checklist before you pay someone who says they will grow your career

• Get everything in writing. No handshake deals for money or long term rights.
• Confirm the term length and the sunset clause in plain language you can read aloud to a friend.
• Separate publishing and master rights from management duties unless you have consulted an attorney and it makes sense for your long term plan.
• Ask for references and contact other artists who worked with them. Ask how long the manager kept claiming money after they parted ways.
• Budget for legal review. Consider this like insurance that costs less than paying someone forever.
• If the contract looks like a trap walk away. People respect boundaries far more than they respect panic signs.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access