How to Write a Song About Alternate Realities

You want to write a song that takes listeners into a different world and makes them stay there. Not a bland sci fi postcard. Not a vague metaphor that sounds clever and then evaporates. You want texture, rules, stakes, and feelings that land like a fist or a feather depending on the moment. This guide teaches you how to build alternate realities for songs in ways that are musical, emotional, and absolutely replayable.

This is for artists who live for weird ideas and for those who are tired of writing the same heartbreak song with different names. It is for writers who want to imagine a roommate who is a time traveler, a city where rain falls up, a memory you can visit by subway, or a version of yourself that made different choices. We will cover theme, worldbuilding in lyric, melody choices that sell strange settings, harmony and production tips that create a sense of place, characters and stakes, point of view, structure templates, specific lines you can steal as exercises, and a set of finishing passes that stop the song from collapsing into nonsense.

Why alternate realities make great songs

Alternate realities are permission to do three things music loves: exaggerate, simplify, and reveal. If your lyric stakes are literal and small you will have trouble hooking a listener. If you give yourself an impossible rule such as a city that remembers names, you get immediate emotion and metaphor without explaining everything. The strange setting becomes a tool to talk about identity, regret, joy, or power.

Think of alternate realities as metaphors that are allowed to be literal for the duration of the track. Listeners accept that bargain when the song promises an experience and then delivers consistent sensory detail. When you place the listener inside a rule based world you can reveal character through how they react to that rule. The world does half the telling for you.

Pick a central rule

The first step is simple. Decide the rule that makes this reality different. A rule is a compact idea you can say in one sentence. Rules create limits and also provide the source of drama. Examples of clear rules you can sing about right now.

• In this city you can visit your parallel life in an arcade machine for one coin.
• Every lie becomes a color you must wear the next day.
• Your phone shows messages from the version of you that never left home.
• Time runs backwards on Thursdays.

Each of these is a tool. Keep it small. The song will be stronger if the rule is specific and narrow. A world that is too expansive becomes an explanation swamp. A single vivid rule gives you endless scenes.

Turn the rule into an emotional promise

Songs need emotion first. A cool world is not enough if listeners do not feel something. For every rule ask this question. What does this rule allow me to say about love, regret, freedom, or identity? Your emotional promise is one sentence that defines the song feeling. Examples.

• Regret looks like a museum you can no longer enter.
• Freedom tastes like the first time you leave without looking back.
• Loneliness becomes louder when other people wear your secrets as clothes.

Make that sentence plain and brutal. This is your compass. If a lyric idea does not support the promise, delete it or file it for another song.

Choose a point of view and stick to it

POV stands for point of view. It is who is telling the story. Use first person if you want intimacy. Use second person when you want to put the listener inside the world as an actor. Use third person to observe and create distance. In songs about alternate realities most powerful options are first person and second person.

First person lets you explore how the rule affects someone intimately. Example sentence: I plug my quarter into the arcade and the version of me who stayed waves like a movie star. Second person turns the song into an invitation. Example sentence: You wear the color that your lies made you and the bar notices. Choose one voice early and keep it consistent. Shifts in POV can work only if they are intentional and signal a structural change such as a bridge.

Use sensory rules to make the unreal feel real

Sensory detail is the difference between a concept and a place you can stand inside. Describe what sounds, smells, textures, and small rituals exist because of the rule. Do not explain everything. Offer a handful of images that repeat and change meaning as the song continues.

Imagine a city where memories are taxied in jars. Sensory lines you can use.

• The jars clink like loose teeth on the backseat.
• Taxi meters count tears in slow motion.
• Drivers ask for directions to the childhood aisle.

One repeated sensory image becomes a hook. The jars clink line can reappear in the chorus as a symbol for how fragile memory is or in the bridge as proof of a decision you made. Repetition builds recognition without explaining the rules again.

Make the chorus the rule revealed emotionally

The chorus is the place where the rule and the emotional promise meet. Do not use the chorus to teach the mechanics. Use it to state the feeling that the rule generates. Keep the language plain and repeatable. A listener should be able to text the chorus to their friend and the line still have power.

Example chorus idea for the taxi jar city.

I ride with your childhood in a glass that rattles like a name. I ask the driver if you remember me and he says maybe in a different life. Repeat that with a tighter melody and a hooky phrase like glass that rattles. The chorus should sing like one idea repeated with a twist.

Characters and stakes

Even in a world that is wildly impossible the song still needs characters who want something. Give your protagonist a clear desire and an obstacle that is tied to the rule. Stakes can be small and human rather than global. The cost of failing is emotional and specific.

For the phone that shows messages from other versions of you, stakes might be.

• Desire: To know whether you would be happier if you had chosen differently.
• Obstacle: Every message from the other you changes one memory in this life.
• Cost: You might lose the memory of the last conversation you had with someone you love.

The best stakes are paradoxical. They feel beneficial but they hurt. The character must choose because the rule creates a menu of temptations that have consequences.

Structure templates to try

Below are three structure templates you can use to turn a rule into a full song. I will call them Map A, Map B, and Map C so you do not get stuck on genre ideas. Pick the one that matches your story pace.

Map A: Build to a reveal

• Intro with a small world detail
• Verse one sets the scene and introduces the rule
• Pre chorus raises a question or shows conflict
• Chorus states the emotional promise
• Verse two adds a character action and raises stakes
• Pre chorus repeats or intensifies
• Chorus with a slight lyrical change to show consequence
• Bridge reveals a secret or forces a choice
• Final chorus with an added line or altered last repeat

Map B: The memory loop

• Cold open with the hook or motif
• Verse one is a flashback that shows normal life before the rule affected it
• Chorus shows how the rule reframes the memory
• Verse two shows trying to fix or escape the rule
• Short bridge that cycles memory material into the present
• Repeat chorus with a new ending that indicates either acceptance or loss

Map C: The choice song

• Intro with a motif tied to the rule
• Verse one shows the desire
• Verse two shows the consequences of a small action
• Chorus becomes the voice of temptation or the voice of loss
• Bridge is the choice moment. Minimal instrumentation and a line that changes the chorus on return
• Final chorus resolves into the new reality or into unresolved longing

Melody and harmony tricks to sell strange places

Music is your stage set. Harmony and melody can signal that we are in a different world without any lyric explanation. Use curious chord moves, drones, and melodic intervals to hint at the uncanny.

• Use a sustained drone under the verse to create the feeling of gravity being different. A drone is a single note that holds while chords change above it.
• Borrow one chord from a parallel key to create a lift that feels unnatural. For example in C major use an F minor chord for one bar. That small color shift tells the ear that rules have changed.
• Introduce an unexpected interval in the melody such as a minor sixth leap. Large leaps sound like decisions. Use them for lines that describe crossing thresholds.
• Use modal scales such as the Dorian mode for a magical, haunted vibe. Dorian has a minor quality with a raised sixth that hints at hope in darkness.
• Layer a vocal harmony that does not follow the expected chord. For example sing a third above in the verse and move to a fifth above in the chorus. The mismatch creates tension that the chorus resolves.

Production moves that create place

Production is where you make your alternate reality sound physically different. Small choices can create large illusions.

• Reverb and space. Use a reverb setting that is not typical for pop. A boxy plate can make a world feel like an arcade cabinet. A very long but thin reverb can feel like a canyon of glass where echoes are slow and clear.
• Reverse sounds. Reverse one small instrument hit under a chorus to give the sense that time is bending. Keep it subtle so the ear is nudged but not confused.
• Field recordings. Add a texture that would exist only in this world. For a city that remembers names include a low hum of murmured names under the pre chorus. Record friends whispering names and mix them low.
• Pitch shifting. Slightly pitch shift a backing vocal to sound like a sibling voice from another life. Use it sparingly on the final chorus for emotional weight.
• Automation of filters. Open the filter on the chorus to reveal color like pulling back a curtain. Closed filter in the verse increases closeness and claustrophobia.

Lyric devices that work well

Some lyric devices translate especially well to alternate reality songs.

Rule anchor

Repeat one short phrase that names the rule or the key object. The phrase should be easy to sing and appear in chorus and in a recurring motif. Example: glass jar, coin, the blue street, the name machine.

Contrast swap

Take a common phrase and make it literal in your world. Example: if you sing about a broken heart in a world where hearts are literal glass objects you can write I sweep your pieces into my apron like broken cups.

Rule consequence chain

List three small consequences of the rule that escalate emotion. This works as a pre chorus or second verse device. Example chain: your lies become colors, your closet swells with them, the mirror refuses to call you by the old name.

Callback line

Bring back a line from verse one in the bridge but flip the meaning with one word change. The listener experiences growth or loss without you needing to explain.

Examples and real life scenarios

To make this useful, here are concrete examples you can adapt. Each example contains a rule, an emotional promise, a chorus seed, and a tiny production note you can take to a demo.

Example 1: The post exchange

Rule: In this reality you can send a letter to your alternate self but each letter removes one shared memory from both lives.

Emotional promise: The song is about the cost of curiosity and whether knowing would be worth forgetting.

Chorus seed: I fold my questions into envelopes and watch the mailbox eat my old afternoons. Say that again on a long note with a simple melody. Repeat the image of afternoons being eaten in the bridge but show a specific memory that is gone.

Production note: Use a tape delay on the vocal in the chorus to imply letters traveling through time.

Example 2: Color of lies

Rule: Lies become garments you must wear the next morning.

Emotional promise: The song is about shame, visibility, and how we hide or reveal ourselves.

Chorus seed: You wear my white lie like a coat and everyone stares because truth never matched that shade. The hook is coat and shade. Keep the chorus short and angsty.

Production note: Add a rhythmic scrape of fabric sound under the verses. Sample real clothing rustle for texture.

Example 3: The subway backdoor

Rule: A hidden subway line takes you to versions of a night where you made different choices for one hour only.

Emotional promise: The song grapples with what you would give to undo or to confirm a decision.

Chorus seed: For sixty minutes I ride a train where you said yes and the city sparks like cheap fireworks. End the chorus with a line that shows regret or acceptance. Use a small melodic leap on the word yes for payoff.

Production note: Use a low pedal synth to sound like rails and a repeating percussive motif that mimics train clack.

Rhyme and phrasing strategies

Rhyme can pull a song toward nursery ends if abused. In alternate reality songs your rhyme choices should support the image and your meter. Use internal rhyme, family rhyme, and slant rhyme to keep lines fresh.

• Internal rhyme. Place a short rhyme inside a line to create forward motion. Example: I fold, I float, I forget the last name you called me.
• Family rhyme. Use words that share vowel or consonant families rather than exact matches. This avoids sing song predictability.
• End with a sound image. If possible end the chorus with a consonant that feels like closure such as k or t when the rule creates finality. If the rule creates openness end with a vowel.

Writing exercises to build a world

These drills will get you moving fast. Time yourself and avoid editing too early.

One rule ten lines

Pick one rule. Write ten short lines that show ten different small consequences of that rule. Do not explain the rule. Focus on tiny images. Time ten minutes.

The object swap

Choose a mundane object near you. Reimagine it in your alternate world. Write four lines where the object performs human actions. This trains you to animate props and make them meaningful.

The conversation import

Write two lines that are a text message from your alternate self to you. Then write two lines that are your reply. Keep it honest. Put one surprising detail in the reply that changes stakes.

How to avoid confusion

Alternate reality songs can become chaos if the listener does not feel anchored. Here are rules of clarity.

• Keep the rule simple. Do not stack three main rules in one song.
• Use one repeated sensory anchor such as a sound, an object, or a color so the listener can latch on.
• Keep the chorus emotionally straightforward. Let the verses do the weirdness in images.
• Use a line in the chorus that doubles as a plain emotional statement. The listener should be able to text that line and have it land.
• Test the song on someone who does not know your concept. If they are lost after the first chorus, simplify.

Prosody and singability

Prosody means how words fit the rhythm. The strangest idea will fail if the natural stresses of speech are fighting the beat. Speak your lines out loud at conversation speed before you sing them. Move stressed syllables to strong beats. If a long beautiful word is the emotional focus but is awkward to sing, rewrite with a more singable synonym or reassign it to a melisma where a single syllable can be elongated.

Also pay attention to vowel shapes for high notes. High notes prefer open vowels such as ah and oh. If your title lands on the top note change the vowel or change the note. Even the most poetic phrasing loses power if the singer sounds strained.

Finishing passes to make the song feel lived in

When the draft is done run these passes.

1. World consistency pass. Read every line and ask does this belong to the rule and to the emotional promise. Remove any out of universe detail.
2. Image consolidation pass. Pick three images you love. Make sure each one reappears in some transformed way across the song.
3. Singability pass. Sing through the chorus three times. Mark any line that stalls and simplify it. Replace long words with short ones when clarity is at risk.
4. Sound design pass. Add one small non musical sound that reinforces the rule and place it somewhere repeating like a character. Keep it low so it gels rather than distracting.
5. Feedback pass. Play for two listeners who do not know your concept. Ask what image they remember and what the rule is. If they cannot name it after the chorus rewrite for clarity.

Common mistakes and how to fix them

Writers frequently fall into traps when dealing with unreal settings. Here are the traps and patch kits.

Too much world, not enough feeling

Fix by asking what the protagonist wants and making that want the engine of the song. Trim world details that do not change the want or the cost.

Over explanation

Fix by trusting the listener. Use one or two potent images and repeat them. Remove lines that explain the mechanics of the rule unless the song needs a technical moment for stakes.

Cliched metaphors

Fix by making images specific and tactile. Replace a line like my heart is broken with a small visual tied to your rule such as my heart is a museum door I pry open once and the exhibits file out.

Confusing pronoun switch

Fix by keeping your point of view consistent. If you must switch perspective make it clear with an instrumental break or a very different melodic phrase.

How to make the song viral ready without cheap tricks

Alternate reality songs have a built in advantage for social platforms because they invite curious takes and characters. To make your song shareable do these things.

• Include a one line chorus hook that can be said on camera in a TikTok or short clip. Make it a small image or a rule phrase.
• Create a visual motif that can be replicated with one prop for fans. For example a specific colored scarf, a jar, a quarter, a paper train ticket.
• Leave space in the track for voice over or for fans to add their alternate reality versions in a duet format.
• Record a short acoustic version that highlights the lyric. People will duet that.

Songwriting prompts you can use now

• Write a song where every truth you say becomes the weather for the day.
• Write about a cafe where patrons can swap memories for coffee beans. Who sits alone and why.
• Write from the perspective of the person who works at the machine that prints alternate outcomes. They are tired and they judge choices.
• Write a chorus that uses the phrase in another life as a ring phrase. Make it mean different things in verse and in bridge.

Examples of opening lines you can steal and twist

Use these as seeds. Change a noun, change the rule, keep the feeling.

• The street lights spell our old names and nobody looks up anymore.
• I drop a coin in the arcade and a version of you steps out with new hands.
• My lies hang from the coat rack like wet umbrellas nobody claims.
• Once a week the subway lets me try the yes that I never said.

FAQ

What if I cannot decide on one rule?

Pick the rule that hits you in the chest first. If two rules are fighting you, choose the one that creates the clearest emotional question. You can keep the other idea as a lyrical image but do not let it become a second rule that muddies the song.

Can alternate reality songs be simple?

Yes. Simplicity often makes the idea more accessible. A single, simple rule with a solid emotional core will connect more than a complex world that demands reading the liner notes. Think of your song as a postcard from a world. You describe a few things and let the listener fill the rest with imagination.

How do I write a title that works for an alternate reality song?

Titles that name the rule or name the central object are effective. Short works best. If the rule is named in the title the song has a clear hook such as The Coin or Glass Jar. If you prefer a phrase use one that is singable and resonates with the emotional promise such as If I Rode the Train.

Should I explain the rules in my press materials or let the song stand alone?

Let the song stand alone. Good songs tell their story within three minutes. Use interviews or social posts to expand the world but do not rely on them to make the song understandable. If you need a paragraph to explain the song before anyone hears it, your song needs clearer signposts.

How do I make the chorus memorable in these songs?

Make the chorus a plain emotional line that uses one image from your world. Keep it short and repeat it. Add a melodic lift into the chorus height and consider a small production change such as opening the filter or adding a vocal harmony to signal importance.

Action plan to write your alternate reality song today

1. Write one sentence that states the rule. Keep it under twelve words.
2. Write one sentence that states the emotional promise. Keep it visceral and plain.
3. Draft ten images that come from the rule. Use five minutes and do not edit.
4. Pick a structure template and map sections in one page. Aim to hit the chorus within the first minute.
5. Sing on vowels over a simple two chord loop for two minutes to find a melody for the chorus. Place your title or rule phrase on the most singable note.
6. Write verse one with one sensorial image and a small action. Keep the world consistent.
7. Record a rough demo and play it for one friend who knows nothing about the idea. Ask them what image they remember. Adjust accordingly.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access