Admin Deal That Sweeps In Legacy Works - Traps & Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

If you own songs from before streaming swallowed the planet, someone will try to eat your catalog like it is an all you can eat buffet. Admin deals can be a legit way to get your legacy works collected, monetized, and properly registered. Or they can be a cleverly dressed con where you sign away future income and control while the other party smiles and invoices you for mysterious fees.

This guide is for musicians, estates, and indie labels who want to be ruthless about protecting legacy catalogs. We will explain what an admin deal is in plain English. We will translate industry shorthand and acronyms. We will show real life scams and how they play out. We will give you contract language to demand and a practical step by step checklist you can use before you sign anything. Read this now or cry later when your best song pays your rent for the other person instead of you.

What Exactly Is an Admin Deal

Admin is short for administration. An admin deal is an agreement where a publisher or admin company handles the business tasks for your songs. Those tasks include registering songs with performing rights organizations, collecting mechanical and performance royalties, issuing licenses, and paying you your share. It sounds boring and that is the point. The work is data heavy and requires relationships and systems. A good admin partner does the plumbing so your money flows where it belongs.

Key players and terms.

• Publisher A company that owns or administers publishing rights. Publishing means the rights to the composition of a song. That is lyrics and melody not the recording.
• Admin company A company that administers rights but does not claim ownership. They collect royalties and take a fee for services.
• PRO Short for performing rights organization. These are societies that collect performance income when your songs are played on radio, TV, streaming services with public performance, live shows, and venues. Examples include ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC in the United States. In the UK PRS for Music and in many other countries there are local PROs.
• Mechanical royalties Payments for reproductions of the composition. On digital services there is a mechanical right for the composition. Mechanical in the modern digital world includes streaming mechanicals and downloads.
• Sub publishing When an admin or publisher assigns foreign collection to a third party to collect in overseas territories.
• Legacy works Songs written and released in the past that form a catalog. These can be small catalogs of indie tracks or massive legacy catalogs from established artists.
• Catalog Your body of songs treated as an asset. Catalog sale means selling ownership of those songs.

An admin company can be wonderful. They can find unpaid uses, register missing splits, collect performance money your old publisher missed, and chase mechanical income from around the world. The risk is that some companies will ask for more than admin rights while promising admin level help. That is how deals sweep in legacy works for pennies on the dollar.

Why Admin Deals Matter for Legacy Works

If you wrote songs in a previous era you likely have paperwork gaps. Metadata is messy. Splits might be undocumented. Old deals often did not register songs correctly with PROs. That means passive income sits uncollected on servers or in foreign collection houses. An admin deal can tidy that up and convert dust into checks.

But legacy catalogs are attractive. They are predictable cash flows. That makes them targets. A predator will promise discovery of lost income while inserting terms that capture control or ownership. They will promise to re register works and then include a clause that transfers rights as a condition. They will offer advances that look like free money and then use recoupment clauses to keep your catalog hostage until the advance is paid back plus fees.

Real Life Scams and How They Run

Here are real world scenarios played out in different flavors. Names changed to protect the gullible.

The Friendly Collector

Case. Sam has a ten song catalog from the early 2000s that was never fully registered with PROs. Bluebird Admin emails Sam saying they will register everything, chase unpaid royalties, and fix splits. They ask Sam to sign an admin agreement that says they will have exclusive admin rights worldwide for the life of copyright. Sam thinks exclusive admin is normal and signs. Two years later Bluebird refers to themselves as publisher and refuses to assign sub publishers without a fee. Sam discovers that Bluebird interpreted exclusive admin to include the ability to issue licenses that lock third parties out unless Bluebird consents. Sam now pays a steep fee to get the rights back.

Lesson. Ask what exclusivity actually allows. Does it allow the admin to license sync for the composition without your explicit approval? Does it allow sub publishing with markups? If the language is vague you lose.

The Advance Trap

Case. Maria needs cash and an admin company offers a tempting advance on expected future royalties. The offer comes as an advance against admin collected income. The agreement says the advance is recoupable from all sources including foreign collections and neighboring rights that the admin will register. After the advance is paid Maria notices odd accounting where the admin prorates overhead and charges bank fees plus an admin fee on top of their regular commission. The advance eats through future income for years.

Lesson. Advances are not free money. Understand the waterfall and the accounts from which recoupment occurs. Ask if the advance is recoupable only from new collections that the admin generates or from all future collections globally. Narrow recoupment if you can.

The Title Claim Switch

Case. A small company promises to clear ownership to make songs more licensable. They claim a sweeping right to correct metadata. They then use a claim process to change the registered writer percentages without your consent. By the time the artist notices, the PRO has accepted the change and royalty flows move to another entity.

Lesson. Never sign a clause that allows unilateral metadata changes without your written approval. That is handing them a pen to write you out of your own songs.

Common Red Flags in Admin Agreements

Below are contract areas where scammers hide traps. Read these like your rent depends on it.

• Grant language that looks like administration but transfers ownership Words like assign and grant can be used to create a transfer. Admin rights should be a license to administer not a license to own. Ask for language that explicitly states that ownership remains with you and that the admin has only an exclusive limited right to administer collecting activities.
• Forever term A term that lasts for the life of copyright can be normal in some publishing deals. In admin deals it is a red flag if combined with broad licensing authority. Demand a defined term with renewal options or a right to terminate for material breach.
• Unlimited recoupment When an advance is recoupable from everything including writer share and international collections that you already owned, that can strip income away. Insist on clear recoupment sources and an accounting schedule.
• Excessive commission plus fees Standard admin commissions range from 10 percent to 25 percent depending on services. Anything much higher should be justified. Watch for layered fees such as a separate foreign sub publisher markup, conversion fees, or data clean up fees that sit outside the commission. Those add up fast.
• Broad sublicensing power Make sure the admin cannot sublicense or sub publish without your permission or at least without writing that guarantees reasonable market rates for sub publishers. You want transparency when your rights move overseas.
• Audit limitations and long audit windows You need the right to audit the admin records. A 90 day audit right that expires five years after the deal ends is weak. Demand a reasonable audit window and clear remedies if discrepancies are found.
• Metadata control If the agreement allows metadata edits without prior approval you risk losing splits. Metadata is the currency of the modern music business. Lock it down.

How Scammers Use Language to Trick You

Contracts are word salad they sprinkle over the truth to make you nod. Here is how they play it.

• They bury transfers in operational clauses Example. A clause that says the admin may assign its rights to an affiliate for operational purposes can be written so broadly that the affiliate becomes a buyer. Then your admin deal becomes a stealth sale.
• They use vague experience claims to justify fees Promises to exploit a catalog worldwide are great. But when they promise to do so without metrics they can charge for every email. Ask for KPIs and reporting frequency. If they cannot provide a track record do not sign.
• They overload you with tech talk They will talk about ISRC codes, ISWC codes, and mechanical splits to make you feel dumb. Learn the basics. ISRC is the recording identifier. ISWC is the composition identifier. If you understand these two items you cannot be gaslit on basic registration.

Market Norms for Admin Fees and Terms

What should you expect from a fair admin deal? Use these norms as a sanity check.

• Commission Typically between 10 percent and 20 percent of publisher share. If they want more ask why and demand added services in writing.
• Term Two year initial term with automatic renewal unless one party provides termination notice. For legacy catalogs you may accept a longer initial term but add review clauses and reversion rights.
• Territory Worldwide is common for admin agreements. If worldwide, require transparent sub publisher agreements and reporting for international collections.
• Advance Only if you need it. Expect lower advances from admin companies than from full publishers because admin companies are not buying rights. Treat advances as loans against collections and narrow recoupment sources.
• Audit Annual reports and the right to audit every 18 to 36 months with a mid clause that the admin pays for the audit if discrepancies exceed a certain threshold is fair.

Essential Clauses You Must Demand

Ask for these clauses written exactly or with similar effect. If they balk get help from a music attorney. These are non negotiables when your legacy works are at stake.

Ownership Clause

Language that states you retain all ownership of the composition rights and that the admin is only granted an exclusive limited right to administer the rights on your behalf. No transfer of ownership may occur under this agreement.

Data And Metadata Clause

All metadata changes require your prior written approval. The admin will provide a metadata manifest for your review before submitting to any PROs or third parties.

Scope Of Authority Clause

Define which rights the admin may exercise. For example include registration and collection activities but exclude sync licensing and assignment of rights without explicit authorizations.

Recoupment And Waterfall Clause

Spell out exactly which revenue streams are subject to recoupment of any advance. Ideally recoup only from collections directly generated by the admin work. Exclude writer share remittances already being paid by other parties unless explicitly agreed.

Termination And Reversion Clause

State what happens when the deal ends. All administration rights revert to you immediately. The admin will deliver a complete account and all data within 30 days of termination. If reversion does not occur automatically the deal is a trap.

Sub publishing And Assignment Clause

The admin may not assign, sublicense, or delegate without your written approval. If sub publishing is used the admin must provide copies of sub publisher agreements and the exact commission rates charged.

Audit Rights Clause

You have the right to inspect accounting records related to your catalog at least once every 24 months. The admin must produce records in electronic format within 30 days of a written request.

Due Diligence Checklist Before You Sign Anything

Do this. Do not skip this. Use it like a Tinder profile before you swipe right on a company with a slick logo.

1. Get the entity information. Check company registration, directors, and any related entities. Use the secretary of state or equivalent in their jurisdiction.
2. Ask for references. Call two clients who are not on their website. Ask how quickly money arrives and how easy reporting is.
3. Request a sample accounting report and a sample sub publisher agreement.
4. Check for conflicts. Are they representing other parties with similar catalogs and could that create a split of interest?
5. Request a full list of fees. If an admin refuses to list all fees in writing walk away.
6. Confirm technology. Ask how they submit to PROs and mechanical agencies. Request explanations for ISWC and mechanical split handling so you understand the workflow.
7. Get everything in writing. Verbal promises are meaningless when the contract says otherwise.

Negotiation Tips That Actually Work

Negotiating an admin deal is not poetry. It is a power game. Here are practical moves.

• Start with a limited trial Offer a trial term on a subset of the catalog. See results. If they deliver then expand the scope.
• Cap fees and markups If they use sub publishers demand a fixed markup and an itemized list of foreign collections. Do not accept vague promises about better foreign rates without proof.
• Push for performance metrics Ask for KPIs like number of registrations completed in the first 90 days, expected unregistered works found percentage, and timeline for collections. Make part of the compensation tied to hitting KPIs if possible.
• Limit recoupment If you must take an advance limit recoupment to newly collected monies generated by the admin. Exclude pre existing streams unless you explicitly agree otherwise.
• Insert audit triggers Have a clause that requires the admin to pay the cost of an audit if discrepancies exceed a small percentage like 2 percent of reported income.

How To Reclaim Rights If You Were Tricked

If you suspect you signed a bad deal take these steps fast.

1. Stop communication that creates new obligations. Keep records of emails and calls.
2. Get a lawyer who specializes in music publishing. Do not go to a generalist who thinks publishing is about sheet music.
3. Request a full accounting immediately. Many agreements limit remedies to accounting disputes so force the issue by demanding numbers in writing.
4. Search for metadata changes at PROs. If someone changed splits without signatures you can file a dispute with the PRO. They usually have processes to freeze distributions while the dispute is resolved.
5. If paperwork shows an assignment not intended by you the case may be theft by false representation. A rights attorney can advise on rescission and damages.

Protecting Legacy Works With Technical Clean Up

Sometimes the fix is not legal. It is data. Here is a playbook.

• Collect original paperwork Writer agreements, split sheets, copyright registrations, ISWC notices, and any prior publisher agreements. Scan everything into a secure cloud folder.
• Register everything Make sure your songs are registered with the correct PRO and that writer splits match your split sheet. For mechanicals in the United States register compositions with the mechanical licensing collective if you are a digital service provider or use proper distribution channels.
• Metadata manifest Create a spreadsheet with song title, writers, splits, ISWC, ISRC, release date, publisher name, and any prior publishers. This is the single source of truth you will present to admins or attorneys.
• Fix orphan works If rights are unclear, create affidavits or collect statements from co writers. Some collection societies will accept documentation to unlock cash.

Sample Language You Can Use

Copy paste is tempting but get an attorney to adapt this to your situation. Still this will help you know what to ask for.

Ownership

"Publisher or Admin Party acknowledges that all right title and interest in and to the Compositions are and shall remain the sole and exclusive property of the Writer Party. No assignment of ownership is granted by this Agreement. Admin Party is granted a non exclusive license to perform administrative registration and collection services only."

Metadata Changes

"Admin Party shall not modify author credit composer credit or split percentages in any registration or third party database without prior written consent of Writer Party. Admin Party shall provide a metadata manifest to Writer Party within thirty calendar days of execution of this Agreement."

Recoupment

"Any advance paid by Admin Party to Writer Party shall be recoupable only from new collections generated by Admin Party work and any sub publishing commissions received by Admin Party as a direct result of Admin Party activities on the Catalog. Recoupment shall not apply to writer share already being collected by third parties prior to execution."

Termination

"Upon termination for any reason all administration rights granted hereunder shall immediately revert to Writer Party and Admin Party shall within thirty calendar days deliver all registration records royalty statements and metadata in machine readable format."

Choosing Between Admin And Selling Your Catalog

Sometimes a straight sale is the right move. Other times you only need admin help. How to decide.

• Selling Means transferring ownership for a lump sum. You lose future income but get cash now. That is useful for major expenses or strategic moves. A sale usually comes with an evaluation of projected income and often a non refundable component.
• Admin Keeps ownership with you and pays the admin a commission on collections. You keep upside. Admin deals are for people who want control and ongoing income.

Ask yourself practical questions. Do you need cash now more than future income? Do you want control of licensing decisions? Do you trust the buyer or admin company with your legacy? Answer honestly and get legal advice.

What To Ask A Lawyer

Bring these concrete questions to your attorney so the meeting is fast and useful.

• Does the grant language actually transfer ownership or is it an administration license?
• Are there any implied transfers via affiliate assignment clauses?
• Is the recoupment waterfall fair and properly limited?
• Are the reporting obligations clear and frequent enough to detect issues early?
• Does the termination clause give me immediate reversion of all rights and data?
• If metadata was changed how can I get splits corrected at the PRO and will that recover past royalties?

Action Plan: Step By Step Before You Sign

1. Create a metadata manifest for your legacy catalog. This is your single source of truth.
2. Request a written service level agreement that includes KPIs and reporting cadence from any admin company.
3. Have a lawyer review grant language and the recoupment waterfall. Focus on ownership and reversion.
4. If offered an advance, narrow recoupment and demand an itemized accounting schedule showing how the advance will be repaid.
5. Insist on written approvals for any metadata or split changes before they are submitted to PROs or third parties.
6. Run a three party background check. Company records public filings and two references not on the website.
7. Sign a short pilot agreement for a subset of works. If they perform you expand. If not you stop and reclaim your rights easily.

FAQ

What is the difference between an admin deal and a publishing deal

An admin deal is a service agreement where the admin handles registration collection and reporting on your behalf. You keep ownership of the composition. A publishing deal typically involves transferring some or all of the publisher share in exchange for promotion advances or other support. Publishing deals often include ownership rights or long term control while admin deals are meant to be limited to administration.

Are admin fees negotiable

Yes. Commission rates and additional fees are negotiable. Use market norms to push back. If the admin wants a higher percentage ask for more services such as audit recovery aggressive foreign pursuit or upfront data clean up and get those promises in writing and tied to KPIs.

Can someone change my splits at a PRO without my permission

They should not and many PROs require proof of agreement before accepting changes. If splits are changed without consent file a dispute immediately with the PRO. Keep split sheets and songwriter agreements to prove your case. If the admin agreement gave them authority then the dispute becomes more complex.

What is a sub publisher and why does it matter

A sub publisher is a local partner in another territory responsible for registering collecting and sometimes licensing your compositions. Sub publishers take a commission for their work. If your admin company uses sub publishers without transparency you may be double charged. Ask for a list of sub publishers and the rates they will charge before signing.

If I sign an admin deal can I still license my songs for sync myself

Depends on the scope of authority. If the admin agreement restricts sync rights the admin may require you to route sync opportunities through them. Insist on carve outs for direct sync opportunities or at least a required written consent process that gives you control and fair split of fees.

How long should an admin term be for legacy works

A two year initial term with renewal options is reasonable. For legacy catalogs you can accept longer terms if you secure reversion triggers tied to performance or breach. Avoid life of copyright terms that allow the admin to hold control indefinitely without meaningful obligations.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access