Distributor Keeps Advances If You Leave - Traps & Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

Look. You signed for an advance, you celebrated, you bought ramen that was finally not instant. Then you tried to leave the distributor and suddenly your advance is the property of something called recoupment forever. Welcome to the horror show. This guide will make that horror show stop. You will learn what the scary words mean, how those words can be used to trap you, and the exact things to say to not get played. No legal gibberish. No lawyer speak that makes your brain melt. Real talk, real steps, and contract lines you can actually use.

This is written for artists who want to keep their money and their masters while still getting the distribution muscle they need. We will cover the difference between distributors and labels, what an advance actually is, common tricks companies use to keep your cash after you leave, and the negotiation moves that will save your career and your bank account. We will include sample clause translations and a practical checklist you can use before you sign or if you already signed and want out.

Why Distributors Give Advances and How Recoupment Works

First, let us be real. An advance is not a gift. It is a loan against future earnings. The company gives you cash now expecting to collect that same amount back from your streaming royalties, download sales, sync fees, or whatever income flows through their system. That process of getting the advance back out of your future income is called recoupment. Simple enough, right. But it gets messy fast because contracts can define which revenue sources are subject to recoupment, how long the company can recoup, and what happens if you leave.

Important jargon explained in plain English

• Advance A lump sum paid to you up front. Think of it as a loan the distributor expects to recover from your earnings.
• Recoupment The process of deducting the advance from the money you would otherwise receive. If you earn money, the distributor subtracts their cut until the advance is recovered.
• Royalty Your share of income from a sale or stream. For example, when a song streams, a tiny pool of money is created. Your royalty is your slice of that pool after the distributor takes its agreed share.
• Net receipts Money the distributor actually receives from DSPs and partners after platform fees and third party cuts. Contracts often say royalties are a percentage of net receipts.
• Gross receipts The total money before deductions. Rarely what artists get paid from because platforms take their cut first.
• Exclusive vs nonexclusive Exclusive means you gave the distributor sole rights to distribute the work. Nonexclusive means you can use others too. Exclusive agreements can lock you in and make it harder to leave with any leverage.
• Survivorship clause A clause that allows the distributor to recover money from future earnings even after the agreement ends. This is where many artists get trapped.
• Sunset clause A clause that says the distributor can keep taking a share for some time after the deal ends, usually with the share percentage declining over time.
• ISRC International Standard Recording Code. A unique identifier for each master recording. It matters because it ties streams and sales to your record.
• UPC Universal Product Code. The barcode for a release. Useful for tracking sales across stores.
• DSP Digital Service Provider. Streaming platforms like Spotify and Apple Music.
• PRO Performing Rights Organization. Entities like ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC that collect performance royalties for songwriters and publishers.

How Companies Turn a Normal Advance Into a Trap

There are several common patterns used by shady operators or careless contracts to keep an advance when you leave. Some of these are deliberate traps. Some are ambiguous clauses that will be aggressively interpreted in the company favor. Knowing the patterns gives you the ability to spot them fast.

Trap 1: Recoup forever via a survivorship clause

The distributor includes a clause that says they can recoup the advance from any income your recordings generate forever. You leave. You sign with another distributor or a label. Streams and sync fees from your songs still come in. The original distributor claims those earnings and keeps deducting until their books say the advance is recouped. That can take years. Worst case scenario, you never see the advance again and you lose out on long term earnings.

How to spot it in the contract Look for words like the company may recoup from any and all income generated by the recordings now and in the future. If the clause says recoupment survives termination it is a red flag.

Trap 2: Recoup from everyone by defining revenue too broadly

Some contracts do a bait and switch by defining royalty sources so broadly that everything you ever earn from the song is fair game. Mechanical royalties, performance royalties, sync, brand deals, physical sales, direct to fan sales, and even merchandise revenue linked to the recording can be included. That gives the distributor a grabber hand into income streams they did not actually provide services for.

How to spot it Check the definitions section for royalty streams subject to recoupment. If it uses language like all monies derived directly or indirectly from the masters you are in trouble. That phrase is a classic broadness trap.

Trap 3: Using advances as a buyout disguised as recoupable cash

They give you a one time advance and call it recoupable. The contract says you received an advance in consideration for assigning certain rights or for granting exclusive distribution. Then they quietly keep the advance but also keep rights to the masters forever. You end up with neither long term control nor the money. That is a buyout masquerading as a loan.

How to spot it Watch for language that says payment is in consideration for assignment of rights or for an exclusive license. If the payment is tied to a transfer of ownership, that is not an advance in the artist friendly sense. Get clarity before any cash changes hands.

Trap 4: Weird accounting rules and excessive deductions

Some distributors use creative accounting to make the advance look like it is not recouped, even when your catalog is earning. They deduct technical fees, data fees, chargeback reserves, minimum delivery fees, exit fees, and more. Each line item reduces the money counted as available to recoup the advance, so the advance lives forever.

How to spot it Check the list of permitted deductions and ask for a sample royalty statement. If there are more than two obscure fee types and none of them are capped, ask hard questions and push for limits. Also demand clarity about platform reversals and chargebacks and how those are handled in practice.

Trap 5: Long term exclusive term with no reversion

A long term exclusive agreement that also allows survivorship means the company can recoup forever while still owning or controlling distribution rights. You may try to leave but the company still controls the pipeline that puts money in their hand first. That removes nearly every path to cut them off.

How to spot it Check the term length and whether rights revert automatically on termination or require a separate action by you. Short terms with clear reversion are safer.

Real Life Scenarios You Will Recognize Instantly

These are small true to life stories that show how the traps play out. Names are fictional but the moves are not.

Scenario 1: Rina and the never ending recoupment

Rina is an indie artist who signed with an aggregator that offered a 2 000 dollar advance. She used the money to finish her EP and to pay a video director. Two years later she got a better offer from a label and moved distribution. Streams kept coming in. That old aggregator sent statements showing zero available balance. Their explanation was technical deductions and platform reversals. The contract had a survivorship clause. After months of audits and invoices Rina saw almost no pay out. She lost the advance and long term royalties went slower to reach her because the aggregator kept taking their cut on streaming only after the platform fees. She had not insisted on limitations in the recoupment clause.

Scenario 2: Sam and the exclusive trap

Sam signed an exclusive distribution and marketing deal that granted the distributor a license for ten years. He took a sizable advance and scaled his touring. A year later the distributor washed his catalogue through a content farm and pushed his recordings into niche bundles. Sam tried to leave and go back to self distribution. The distributor insisted on their contract terms and continued to claim revenues from all DSPs under their exclusive license. Sam had given away too much of his rights because he wanted quick money and a marketing promise.

Scenario 3: Band and the admin fee rabbit hole

A four piece band agreed to a distribution deal where the distributor would also manage publishing administration. The advance was small but real. Every royalty statement showed a long list of admin and service fees. Some were legitimate. Some were not explained. The band never saw transparent third party invoices. That made it impossible to verify charges. They signed without an audit window. When they left the distributor kept applying those fees to future earnings and the recoupment balance hardly budged.

How to Read Key Contract Clauses and What to Ask For

Below are the clauses you must inspect before you sign. For each clause we translate the legalese to artist friendly language and provide example alternative wording you can propose. Use this as your redline cheat sheet.

Advance clause

What it often says Legal language might read seller shall be paid an advance recoupable from net receipts in respect of the masters.

Plain english translation They gave you an advance and they will take it back from your future income that passes through them. That is fine as a basic loan but you need limits.

Suggested artist friendly wording The advance is repayable only from revenue generated by the masters during the term of this agreement and shall not be recoupable against monies derived from the masters following expiration or termination of this agreement. The distributor may not recoup from future earnings after the contract ends.

Recoupment and survivorship clause

What it often says Distributor shall be entitled to recoup unpaid advances and costs from any amounts payable to the artist now or in the future in respect of the masters.

Plain english translation This means they can take the advance out of your money for as long as they like even after you leave.

Suggested artist friendly wording Distributor may recoup the advance only from revenue generated by the masters during the term of this agreement. Any amounts earned following termination shall be payable to the artist without deduction for recoupment, except for amounts already withheld in good faith by the distributor prior to termination due to platform reversals and chargebacks, which shall be limited to a single accounting period and documented in writing.

Exclusivity clause

What it often says Artist grants an exclusive license to distribute and exploit the masters throughout the territory for the term of this agreement.

Plain english translation You cannot use another distributor for those masters while this contract is active. That makes negotiating leverage very small.

Suggested artist friendly wording Artist grants a nonexclusive license for distribution only. The artist retains the right to use other distribution channels for nonoverlapping territories and for direct to fan sales. If exclusive terms are requested insist on a limited period no longer than 12 months with an automatic reversion of rights on expiration.

Accounting and audit clause

What it often says Distributor shall provide royalty statements quarterly and payment within 60 days of receipt of monies. Distributor may withhold certain fees and charges.

Plain english translation They will send you numbers and then hold back money for whatever they call fees unless you negotiate limits and audit rights.

Suggested artist friendly wording Royalty statements shall be delivered quarterly with fully itemized entries showing gross receipts, platform fees, third party deductions, and any reserves for chargebacks. The artist shall have the right to audit the relevant books and records once per calendar year at artist expense, recoverable if discrepancies exceeding five percent are found in favor of the artist. All deductions must be supported by written invoices from the third party provider and may not exceed a reasonable and customary market rate for such services.

Reversion clause

What it often says Rights shall revert to the artist on termination upon the artist providing a written request and the fulfilment of certain conditions.

Plain english translation Often the reversion is not automatic. You may have to ask, jump through hoops, or even pay a fee. That is how they keep control.

Suggested artist friendly wording Upon expiration or termination of this agreement all rights granted hereunder shall automatically revert to the artist without further action or payment by the artist, except for the limited right of the distributor to collect and remit amounts accrued but unpaid as of the effective date of termination subject to a six month wind down period. Any wind down shall be narrowly tailored and not extend beyond six months.

Negotiation Moves That Actually Work

You do not need to be a lawyer to ask for these things. You just need to sound like you know what could go wrong and be willing to walk away. Most distributors want product and will accept reasonable requests. Here are the moves that matter.

• Limit recoupment to the term Demand that the distributor can only recoup advances from income generated while the agreement is active. No survivorship.
• Cap deductions Ask for a small list of permitted deductions and a cap on the total percentage taken for admin and technical fees.
• Escrow or installments If the advance is substantial ask for the money to be paid in milestones so you can earn release obligations rather than hand over rights for a single wire.
• Automatic reversion Insist rights revert automatically at the end of the term. No red tape, no reversion fee.
• Audit rights Require an artist audit at least once per year with a clear threshold for cost recovery if material discrepancies are found.
• Short exclusive term If exclusivity is unavoidable keep it short and define territories strictly.
• Waterfall clarity Ask for a sample royalty statement and a plain english description of how revenue flows from the DSP to you.
• Nonassignment of masters Do not allow automatic assignment of masters to third parties. Require your written consent.

Preventive Steps Before You Sign

Before you ever tap accept or initial anything these six actions will save you time and money.

1. Read the whole agreement No, not just the first page. Read the definitions. Read the recoupment rules. If it uses the phrase anything derived directly or indirectly you must ask for changes.
2. Ask for a sample statement If a distributor cannot show you a sample of how they report and what they deduct that is a sign they are not transparent. Walk away or push for clarity.
3. Make the advance conditional If you accept a big advance make it conditional on the distributor confirming in writing that recoupment will end on termination and that rights revert automatically.
4. Register everything Get ISRCs and UPCs for your releases before delivery so streams and sales are tied unmistakably to your records.
5. Keep your masters safe Do not deliver final masters until terms are clear. Keep raw files and session stems in a secure cloud folder so you can show provenance.
6. Hire an entertainment attorney or an experienced manager A one hour consult can save you thousands. If you cannot afford a lawyer use reputable industry organizations that offer contract clinics.

If You Already Signed and Want Out Do This

Leaving is messy but not impossible. The path depends on the agreement language and how aggressive the distributor is. Use these steps in order.

1. Read the termination clause Know the required notice period, payments due on termination, and any wind down obligations.
2. Request a final accounting in writing Ask for a full itemized statement and supporting invoices for deductions. Put a deadline for response.
3. Document everything Save emails, bank deposits, screenshots of streaming counts, proofs of delivery, and release metadata.
4. Negotiate an exit workout Propose that you will repay an agreed portion of the unrecouped advance in installments in exchange for immediate reversion of rights. This often works better than fighting.
5. Invoke audit rights If you have audit rights exercise them. A single audit can reveal overcharged fees that materially change balances.
6. Escalate to dispute resolution If negotiation fails check the contract for arbitration or mediation. Sometimes a neutral third party forces a better outcome than months of vendetta emails.
7. Ask for transparency in writing Demand that any ongoing recoupment be accounted for in monthly statements and limited to revenues collected for activity occurring during the term.

Alternatives to Taking a Distributor Advance

You do not have to take a handout that costs you your future. There are other ways to fund releases without selling your rights or subjecting income to eternal recoupment.

• Crowdfunding Platforms like Kickstarter and Patreon let fans pay for a project upfront without contractual strings.
• Fan presales Offer bundles, vinyl, or exclusive content in presale to fund production.
• Local grants and arts funds City and state arts councils often have grants for music projects.
• Brand partnerships and sync Negotiate direct deals with brands or pitch for sync licensing which can pay well without recoupment chains.
• Micro loans or revenue based financing There are lenders who offer loans against future earnings but these are often clearer and narrower in scope than a distributor recoupment clause.
• Distribution only without advance Many aggregators will distribute for a low fee or a small share and not give an advance. That keeps your long term income clean.

Checklist to Run Before You Sign Any Distributor Contract

• Do they ask for exclusivity and for how long
• Is the advance called an assignment or a license or a loan
• Does recoupment survive termination
• What income streams are subject to recoupment
• Are deductions itemized and capped
• Does the contract show sample royalty statements
• Are audit rights included and reasonable
• Do rights revert automatically on termination
• Is the territory worldwide and is that necessary
• Is there a scenic list of fees that look suspiciously like a money trap

Red Flag Phrases That Mean Trouble

When you see these phrases ask questions. Get answers in writing. Do not sign until you are satisfied.

• Any and all monies derived directly or indirectly from the masters
• Distributor shall be entitled to recoup from any revenue stream now or in the future
• Rights are assigned in consideration of the advance
• Survivorship of recoupment
• Distributor may withhold without itemization
• Artist shall repay any unrecouped balance on demand

How To Spot A Reputable Distributor

Reputation matters. Here are quick checks that separate the folks who play fair from the sharks with suits.

• Transparent accounting practices with sample statements
• Clear limits on deductions and fees
• Simple recoupment rules tied to the term only
• Automatic reversion of rights on termination
• References from artists you can contact
• Willingness to negotiate reasonable contract language

What To Do If You Think You Are Being Scammed

If you suspect a distributor is abusing the contract or misreporting, take these immediate steps.

1. Freeze new uploads and do not hand over new masters until issues are addressed.
2. Request a full accounting and invoices for deductions.
3. Call your PRO and publishing admin and confirm payments they received.
4. Talk to an entertainment lawyer or an industry advocate.
5. Gather evidence. Screenshots, bank statements, emails and sample statements all help.
6. If necessary file a complaint with consumer protection agencies or the Better Business Bureau in your market.

FAQ

Can a distributor legally keep my advance when I leave

Yes if the contract says they can recoup the advance from future earnings even after termination. That is why contract language matters. If the agreement includes survivorship or broad recoupment language the distributor may lawfully use revenues earned after you leave to recoup their advance. The fix is to negotiate recoupment that is limited to the term or to short sunset periods. Ask for automatic reversion and clear limits on deductions.

What is a survivorship clause and why should I fear it

A survivorship clause allows the distributor to keep recouping advances from income after the agreement ends. That means even if you move to a new distributor or sign with a label the old distributor can hang on to a slice of income until their bookkeeping balance is zero. You should avoid or limit survivorship clauses because they can create leaks that drain your long term income.

Should I accept an advance if it means exclusive distribution

It depends on the size of the advance and the term length. Exclusive distribution creates friction when you want to change partners and can give the distributor leverage. If you accept exclusivity make sure the term is short, rights revert on expiration, and recoupment is capped. Consider alternatives like a nonexclusive deal combined with marketing support in trade for performance milestones.

How can I tell if an advance is really a buyout

Read the clause describing the payment. If the payment is described as consideration for assignment of rights or permanent transfer of masters the company is buying rights not giving a loan. If you want to keep ownership ask for an advance that is expressly a recoupable advance and not a consideration for rights transfer.

Can I negotiate the accounting rules

Yes. You should. Ask for itemized statements, caps on deductions, and third party invoice support for any fees. Insist on an audit right and on cost recovery if misreporting favors the distributor. Clear accounting makes it hard for them to hide fees that prevent recoupment.

What is a sunset clause and is it bad

A sunset clause allows the distributor to keep taking a share for a short time after the contract ends usually with the percentage decreasing over time. A reasonable sunset clause is fair because it compensates the distributor for their role in getting the release into stores. An unreasonable one that lasts years or that is at full rate is abuse. Aim for a short sunset like six months to a year with a clear decline in percentage across that period.

If I have already left the distributor how do I stop them from recouping forever

First check the contract for survivorship language. If it is present you might not be able to stop them without negotiation. Ask for a final accounting. Offer to settle for a lump sum smaller than the balance in exchange for reversion of rights. If they refuse consider mediation or arbitration if the contract allows. If there is proof of misreporting use audit results to force correction. A negotiated exit is often faster and cheaper than litigation.

Are small independent distributors safe

Some are great and some are not. Small distributors can be responsive and fair. They can also be sloppy about accounting. The same rules apply. Ask for transparency, sample statements, and an audit clause. Check references and see how other artists feel about them after a few years.

How do I protect publishing and performance royalties from distributor recoupment

Publishing and performance royalties are separate from master revenues and are often collected by your PRO or a publishing administrator. Make sure your publishing is registered properly and consider using a publishing administrator like Songtrust or a direct publisher relationship that receives income separately from the distributor. Explicitly exclude publishing and performance royalties from distributor recoupment in the contract.

Action Plan You Can Use Today

1. Find the distributor contract and read it from definitions to termination. Highlight any mention of recoupment, survivorship, and deductions.
2. Ask the distributor for a sample royalty statement and a list of permitted deductions with invoices as proof.
3. Propose changes using the suggested wording above. Focus on limiting recoupment to the term and getting automatic reversion.
4. Register ISRCs and UPCs for your releases and keep copies of masters and session stems.
5. If you already signed request a final accounting in writing and propose a fair exit payment if you want immediate reversion of rights.
6. Get a short entertainment industry legal review if the advance is significant. A single hour of lawyer time can pay for itself with one saved clause.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access