Most-Favored Nation Promised Verbally Only - Traps & Scams Every Musician Must Avoid

Someone told you you are getting the best deal in the room. They said it in a hallway, over a beer, or on a late night call after a show. That warm glow of validation lasts until the invoice arrives or you see the other artist got a better split. Then the warm glow turns into a text you regret sending. If you were promised Most Favored Nation verbally only you are in an attention worthy minefield.

This guide is for artists managers producers and anyone who gets offered the verbal version of MFN. We will explain what Most Favored Nation means in music deals. We will show the common scams that hinge on a verbal promise. You will get real life scenarios that feel painfully recognizable. You will get exact language you can copy into email or contracts. You will learn negotiation moves and the one sentence you need to stop a rumpled handshake from becoming your lifetime regret.

What is a Most Favored Nation clause

Most Favored Nation usually short MFN is a contract clause that promises one party will get the best terms the other party offers to anyone else. In music that often means if the label distributor manager or publisher gives a better royalty save or right to another artist then you are entitled to the same benefit. The idea is simple and tempting. The execution is where the mess begins.

MFN in plain language

• Party A says you will not get worse terms than anyone else.
• If Party A gives someone else a better term then Party B can get the same term or an adjustment.
• Good MFN provides clarity on scope on timing and on remedy if the better term appears.

Why artists love it

MFN looks like insurance. You want to know you will not be left behind if a bigger act convinces the company to hand out extra perks. If written well MFN can protect your financial upside and your bargaining power when you are small. The problem is most people promise MFN verbally and then hope you do not care enough to force paper and signatures.

Why a verbal MFN is dangerous

Verbal promises are powerful at closing. They make deals feel human and fast. They also vanish like smoke when someone else wants to keep the better slice for themselves. Here is why verbal MFN is an open invitation to trouble.

• No proof A handshake is not a file stamp. Without paper you will have to prove what was promised and that is expensive and messy.
• Vague scope Verbal promises rarely define whether MFN covers royalties sync deals advances territory length or merch splits. Ambiguity kills claims.
• No remedy A good MFN says how you get the better term retroactively and within what time period. A verbal promise often leaves you waiting for a check that never comes.
• Selective memory People forget or intentionally reinterpret conversations. Later they claim the promise was only for something small or only for verbal good faith talks.

Common scams that use verbal MFN as bait

Below are the top scams we see that rely on a verbal Most Favored Nation promise. If any of these sound familiar you have likely been in a room with someone stacking the deck.

1. The promise to match a future distribution deal

Scenario

You sign a distribution deal with a small label or aggregator. The rep says they will always give you the same best payout they give anyone else. Six months later a viral act gets a better royalty and a marketing budget. Your rep says the MFN only applied to streaming royalties and not to the marketing spend. You get no retro payment and no marketing support.

Why it works

Labels split revenue streams into many buckets. If the verbal promise did not define the buckets you lose. The other act got a bundle of perks that cannot be matched with a simple royalty tweak.

2. The manager who promises MFN for song placements

Scenario

Your new manager promises that they will not accept a sync split for any of their clients that is better than yours. They say it on the phone. Later the manager takes a placement for another client at a lower publisher split and pockets a finders fee. You find out when the track plays in an ad and you get only a fraction of what you expected.

Why it works

Managers are rarely regulated and documentation is often limited. Without a written clause that includes audit rights you cannot trace the financial flows easily.

3. The producer who guarantees MFN on beats or work for hire

Scenario

A producer promises you the best production credit and split among their roster. They verbally agree to give you a higher share if they later do better for someone else. Later they sign a lucrative placement and give their high paying client a better split. You are told the producer has no duty to retroactively change past credits or paperwork.

Why it works

Production credits and publishing shares require paperwork. Producers can adjust future deals while leaving your older splits untouched unless you asked for retroactive change in writing.

4. The label that waves MFN like a badge of honor

Scenario

A label promises you MFN as part of the pitch. You sign. The label later negotiates deals with distribution partners and grants exclusivity or better splits to bigger acts. When you ask for the same terms the label claims the MFN was only a marketing promise and not part of the contract.

Why it works

Marketing promises are slippery. Companies rely on your desire to keep the relationship warm. Without a solid clause you are out of luck.

Terms companies use to hide what they give you verbally

Artists get tripped up by language that sounds helpful while narrowing the actual promise. Watch for these traps.

• Best available terms at time of signing This sounds fair but it means you do not get protections for future deals.
• Equivalent distribution Equivalent might be interpreted narrowly by lawyers to exclude any deal that differs even slightly.
• For similar opportunities Similar to what exactly? The ambiguity is useful to the company and deadly to you.
• In our reasonable judgment Reasonable to whom? This puts the company in the driver seat and you in the passenger seat without brakes.

What a proper MFN clause should include

If you are going to insist on MFN here are the elements that make it enforceable and meaningful.

• Clear scope Define exactly what the MFN covers. Royalties mechanical income sync fees advances marketing spend merchandising touring splits territory and length must be explicitly included or excluded.
• Time frame State the time period the MFN applies. Is it for the life of the deal for one year after signing or for the life of the master. Put a clock on it.
• Retroactive adjustment Say how you get the better term. Typically the company must make a retro payment within 30 to 90 days plus interest on unpaid amounts.
• Audit rights You must be able to audit the company records to confirm better deals exist. Define who pays for the audit if you find underpayment.
• Definition of identical terms If the other artist gets a different bundle of rights the clause should explain whether that still triggers MFN.
• Notice and cure Require the company to notify you when it grants a superior term and give you the option to receive the benefit or to terminate certain rights.
• Remedies Define remedies beyond money. This could include release from exclusivity injunctive relief and payment of legal fees if enforcement is required.

Sample MFN clause you can copy and adapt

Make this your starting point and get a lawyer to adapt it to your situation.

Most Favored Nation. If at any time during the Term the Company grants to any third party more favorable economic terms or non economic rights with respect to exploitation of musical recordings substantially similar to the Recordings covered by this Agreement the Company shall within thirty calendar days provide written notice to Artist and shall, at Artist choice, either (a) make Artist whole retroactively by paying Artist the difference plus interest at a rate of five percent per annum from the date such more favorable terms took effect or (b) adjust Artist terms prospectively to match such more favorable terms. Company shall permit Artist or Artist representative to audit Company records no more than once per calendar year at Artist expense unless the audit reveals underpayment of greater than three percent in which case Company shall pay reasonable audit costs.

Do not copy and paste this blind. Use it to understand the mandatory pieces and have a lawyer set it into your actual contract language so it aligns with local law and with the rest of your deal.

How to respond in the moment when someone says MFN verbally

You need quick lines you can use in a meeting or on the phone that shut down vague promises while keeping the room warm enough to keep negotiating. Here are phrases that sound like a pro and sound like a human who is not being played.

• Great. Put that in writing and send me the clause with the exact scope and remedy and I will sign.
• I want that promise to be contractual. Please add an explicit Most Favored Nation clause and show me the retro remedy you use.
• I am happy to move forward if the MFN covers royalties advances and marketing and includes an audit right. Can your counsel draft that today.

These lines force movement. If the other side is confident the promise is empty they will stall. If they do stall you should treat that as a red flag.

Red flags that the MFN is bogus

• They say we always offer MFN but refuse to add language to the contract.
• They say the MFN applies but only to things you cannot audit or that are not tracked in statements.
• They say MFN but add a caveat like for deals of a similar kind as determined by us.
• They claim MFN applies but offer no timeline for retro payments.
• They promise MFN verbally then try to add a clause that says verbal promises are not binding. This is the classic bait and switch.

Real life scenarios that will make you furious and help you learn

Scenario 1 The festival slot that turned into a royalty mismatch

What happened

A band was promised Most Favored Nation status for merch revenue from a club circuit run. The verbal promise came from the booking agent who said the band would get the same cut as the agent s favorite act. After the tour the agent gave the favorite act a higher split and assigned those receipts to a separate company so the tour statements looked different. The band got a smaller share and no retro payment.

Lesson

Define the revenue streams and insist on audit rights. Ask that the MFN apply to all related entities and subsidiaries and say you can audit related party transactions to prevent invoices being shuffled to third party shells.

Scenario 2 The producer split that got rewritten

What happened

A new artist was promised the best publishing split by a producer. The producer later negotiated a sweet sync and allocated the bulk of the publishing share to the new client. The original artist was told the verbal promise applied only to future collaborations and not to the master just completed. No retro split was offered.

Lesson

Define whether the MFN applies to current works to future works or to both. If the producer has the ability to re assign or re register shares you must put contractual guardrails in place and require your name and share to be fixed on registration paperwork.

Scenario 3 The label that said trust us

What happened

A label rep promised that any marketing support given to acts with more plays would also be paid to smaller acts where appropriate. The language was only oral. When a viral artist got a massive budget the label argued that marketing is discretionary and that MFN only applied to net revenue splits not to promotional spend.

Lesson

If you want marketing parity get it written as a defined budget or as a right to a marketing audit. Alternatively get a clause that guarantees a percentage of promotional spend or a minimum campaign size triggered by certain thresholds.

How to convert a verbal MFN into a binding written term

If you already have a verbal promise here are specific steps to make it enforceable.

1. Document the conversation Immediately write an email that summarizes what was said and your understanding. Send it to the person who promised it and to the person who executes contracts. Say please confirm that this matches your understanding. This creates an email trail. Do not be shy about using timestamps and quoting exact words you remember. People do not like having to deny things in writing.
2. Ask for contract language Request the company s counsel to draft the MFN clause. Do not accept a vague sentence in an appendix. Ask for the sample clause to be incorporated into the main agreement.
3. Insist on retrofit If the better terms already exist ask for retro payment and a date by which the payment will be made. Put that timeline in the contract.
4. Add audit and remedies Without audit rights MFN is mostly an honor code. Add language about audit frequency scope and cost allocation if underpayment exceeds a defined threshold.
5. Get signatures Do not accept an emailed promise. Get a signed amendment or a signed contract that includes the MFN clause.

Email template to convert verbal MFN into writing

Copy this and adapt. Send immediately after the verbal promise.

Subject: Confirmation of Our Conversation on MFN

Hi [Name],

Thanks for the call today. I appreciate you offering Most Favored Nation status for my recordings. To make sure we are aligned please confirm the following and if you agree include this language in our agreement.

1. MFN will apply to royalties advances and marketing spend related to exploitation of the Recordings.
2. If Company grants more favorable economic terms or promotional support to any third party for substantially similar recordings Company will within thirty calendar days either pay Artist the difference retroactively or adjust Artist terms prospectively to match those terms.
3. Artist will have the right to audit Company records once per calendar year and Company will pay audit costs if the audit reveals underpayment greater than three percent.
4. Company will notify Artist in writing within ten business days of granting any more favorable terms to a third party.

Please reply to confirm and attach a draft amendment so we can sign this as part of the Agreement.

Thanks,
[Your Name]

How to handle it when you discover you were cheated

Findings of abuse can be ugly. Here are pragmatic steps to recover value and to protect future income.

1. Collect evidence Gather emails statements registration changes and anything that proves the other party gave superior treatment.
2. Send a formal notice Use a strongly worded email requiring immediate accounting and retro payment and give a deadline. Professional and firm beats angry and vague.
3. Propose a fix Offer remedies you prefer. Magic often happens when you propose a concrete monetary number or a release from obligations in exchange for settling.
4. Escalate to counsel If the other side ignores you call a lawyer. Many disputes resolve the minute counsel is involved because contracts are not cheap to litigate.
5. Use public pressure carefully Calling out a partner on social media can be satisfying. It can also destroy your leverage. Use it only with counsel and with the goal of changing the outcome not with the goal of venting.

When MFN might be overkill

Not every deal needs MFN. Here are times when you can walk away from the discussion and still win.

• If the company is small and you get an above market upfront and you do not care about future parity.
• If you negotiate a meaningful advance or minimum guarantee that secures your runway. A big enough advance can make MFN less vital.
• If your revenue streams are niche and unlikely to be compared to mass market acts. In that case focus on specific carve outs like sync or play listing credits rather than a broad MFN.

How lawyers and business managers actually think about MFN

Business people and lawyers see MFN as either a lever or a risk. For companies MFN creates administrative burden and legal risk. If you ask for MFN they will evaluate the cost and the likelihood you will actually use audit rights. Savvy artists use MFN as a bargaining chip not as the end goal. If the company balks you can pivot to other protections like higher minimum guarantees defined marketing commitments or shorter exclusivity periods.

Negotiation moves that win MFN without sounding desperate

• Swap value Offer a concession in return for MFN. Maybe you accept a lower advance if the MFN includes audit rights and retro payment. Value traded is less threatening than value demanded.
• Use timelines Propose a limited MFN like one year that you can extend if the relationship proves valuable. Companies are more willing to try things that expire.
• Link MFN to triggers Ask that MFN applies only when the company awards a better economic term above a defined threshold. This reduces administrative noise and keeps the clause meaningful.
• Get a good audit clause Companies know audits are expensive. Make it the path of least resistance by building a clean audit protocol and a narrow look back window.

Checklist every musician should use before signing when MFN was promised verbally

1. Get the promise in writing now not later.
2. Confirm what streams and payments MFN covers.
3. Require retroactive remedy and a payment timeline.
4. Include audit rights and cost allocation rules.
5. Define identical or substantially similar deals clearly.
6. Limit MFN by time or by trigger if company resists broad language.
7. Obtain signatures from authorized signatories not just reps.
8. Ask counsel to review the final clause before signing.

Glossary of key terms and acronyms

MFN Most Favored Nation. A contractual promise that you will get the best terms offered to any other party.

Audit rights The contractual right to inspect a company s financial records to confirm payments and accounting.

Retroactive adjustment Payment that brings your effective terms into alignment with a better term that was granted later.

Sync Synchronization license for placing music in film television advertising and other timed media. This is often a major revenue stream and a frequent source of unequal deals.

Work for hire A contractual designation that may assign copyright ownership away from the creator. MFN can intersect with work for hire when producers reassign splits.

FAQ

Is a verbal MFN legally binding

It can be in some jurisdictions but proving it is painfully hard. Written contracts provide clarity and enforcement pathways. You should treat verbal MFN as a conversation starter not as your safety net.

What if the company says no to MFN in writing

Negotiate alternatives. Ask for a higher minimum guarantee a larger advance or a limited MFN for a defined time. You can also secure defined marketing commitments or the right to opt out if the company grants an obvious super deal to another artist.

How much does it cost to enforce MFN if they break it

Costs vary widely. Start with an audit which can be a few thousand dollars. If litigation is required costs escalate into the tens of thousands. That is why strong audit rights and clear remedies in the contract are essential. They reduce the need for expensive escalation.

Can I ask for MFN after I already signed

Yes. Ask for an amendment. Use the email template above and propose clear language and a fair compromise. Companies often accept amendments in exchange for limited concessions.

Does MFN guarantee equal marketing

Not unless you write it that way. Marketing is often excluded or left to company discretion. If marketing parity matters to you write defined budgets campaign sizes or metrics that trigger matching support.

If I get a retro payment do I need to pay tax on it

Usually yes. Retro payments are taxable income and you should speak with an accountant to plan for tax consequences. Keep your books clean and consult a tax pro before accepting large retro payments.

Get Contact Details of Music Industry Gatekeepers

Looking for an A&R, Manager or Record Label to skyrocket your music career?

Don’t wait to be discovered, take full control of your music career. Get access to the contact details of the gatekeepers of the music industry. We're talking email addresses, contact numbers, social media...

Packed with contact details for over 3,000 of the top Music Managers, A&Rs, Booking Agents & Record Label Executives.

Get exclusive access today, take control of your music journey and skyrocket your music career.

Unlock Instant Access